Mafia #76 Game Thread: Revenge of the Nerds

[IceH2O]

I stand corrected, it was Noods who switched 1st not Lab.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Well both were my top suspects, but JMs post and investigation reasons made more sense to me then ballys.



What if the Dr picks wrong?



I switched quickly? Looking back you were the 1st to switch votes. Mine came this morning. If both hadn't claimed your innocents I'd think you were a team mate.


I have a what if too Lab.

What if both JM and Bally are your team mate and the real NG was smart enough to not come out.They both claim you're innocent. We take 1 out and since we see they aren't the NG we think the other one is. If the real NG then comes out they won't be believed and will be voted out. So now you're safe and the fake NG is safe and you easily run the table.

Hopefully the doctor chooses wisely.

Looking back, I was the first to retract, but your scummate DD was the first to switch votes. I held off on my vote until hours later.

That is a creative theory there Ice, but it doesn't hold water. Way too risky for two scum to role claim and just sit there and hope the real NG doesn't role claim too. That exposes two of them. So with your theory, then Dawg would also be scum, since he was named as an innocent by Bally. It was a nice try there but I can't wait to read your scum chat if you and RB are teammates.

 

[IceH2O]

I see no reason for either to come out. JM only had a few votes I think when he decided to come out. 3 or 4 maybe.

I can see why JM came out. If not for FF he would have been lynched yesterday and he had so many fingers pointing his way today it was probably a forgone conclusion in his mind he was next.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I can see why JM came out. If not for FF he would have been lynched yesterday and he had so many fingers pointing his way today it was probably a forgone conclusion in his mind he was next.

Did his coming out mess up your team's plans?

 

[Chill]

i i vote to lynch DD

 

[IceH2O]

Hopefully the doctor chooses wisely.

Looking back, I was the first to retract, but your scummate DD was the first to switch votes. I held off on my vote until hours later.

That is a creative theory there Ice, but it doesn't hold water. Way too risky for two scum to role claim and just sit there and hope the real NG doesn't role claim too. That exposes two of them. So with your theory, then Dawg would also be scum, since he was named as an innocent by Bally. It was a nice try there but I can't wait to read your scum chat if you and RB are teammates.

It exposes 2 of them if we believe the correct one. This doesn't necessarily make Dawg evil as Bally didn't need to name another team mate she could give us an innocent too. You're the only one they both named as innocent.


My theory is out there I admit. I doubt its true myself but it was something I though about reading your posts trying to railroad me and save JM and Bally.

 

[Lab_Rat]

I retract my vote on Ice. I vote to lynch DD.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I can't believe with 10min left till nightfall no one is talking. Especially JM...WTF!!

 

[noodles62]

Well I really have no idea where to go with all this ....stuff, but I think I will leave my vote where it is.

Bob, anytinhg to add? Care to enlighten us with your thoughts?

 

[Lab_Rat]

It exposes 2 of them if we believe the correct one. This doesn't necessarily make Dawg evil as Bally didn't need to name another team mate she could give us an innocent too. You're the only one they both named as innocent.


My theory is out there I admit. I doubt its true myself but it was something I though about reading your posts trying to railroad me and save JM and Bally.

No railroading Ice. I'll happily vote for your teammates too.