Mafia #77 Game thread- Back to the basics

[rich311k]

I imagine the mafia did. Plenty of time to change their hit.

 

[Kashta]

FFS Labby. A wildass theory at the last minute is one thing, but waiting like that when you intend to role claim?? That gave the town absolutely no time to evaluate which part(s) of your post to believe (or discount)... and still have time act upon it.

That role claim alone would have saved you. And without taking out another innocent in your place if you were wrong. Your theory was nothing more than just another theory. But we could have and should have been discussed in the thread if you'd only told everyone that part of it. The scum didn't know your role. And had your theory been correct (which would have implicated you as the doctor as well), then that knowledge would have been WAY more important to the entire town than the life of one townie PR.

 

[jm1212]

darn, this sucks. sorry labby, you really were looking evil with your posts.

that said, at this point Pir and Salt are looking the scummiest to me.

 

[dirtydawg10]

I guess I have time to clear some things up...

1) How I picked the roles is how I picked the roles. Random or not people will form their own suspicions no matter what I say anyways. If it puts your mind to rest, yes they were random. You take that how you want...

2) The blackmail is one time only. I should have made that more black and white in the rules.

3) I will let the PM thing slide since by the looks of it there was no impact on the game other than words becoming a bit too heated. Self moderation is good I suppose but from now on please abide by the rules. No PMs related to the game may be sent between players unless they are authorized to communicate.

Again, I apologize for how little I have been around. Internet is up and running smoothly so I will be able to update more throughout the game from now on. Thanks for your cooperation and all the vote counts for me to double check with....way too many switches going on there...

Thanks for the clarifications JPap.

Thanks for the info...

You're welcome.

 

[RazzleFish]

Guys, instead of complaining about how it went, why don't we try to figure out who would have hit LR?

Who was complaining? We aren't allowed to have reactions?

 

[user_name]

kash, jb's quote in your sig pretty much sums up my feelings for what just happened.

 

[user_name]

darn, this sucks. sorry labby, you really were looking evil with your posts.

that said, at this point Pir and Salt are looking the scummiest to me.

agreed.

 

[Lady G]

OMFG!!! What a mess we have! This whole day one has been a mess, and it ended even worse!

Sucks really bad we lost Labby...but WTH LAB! Loosing Ice was terrible too!!!!!!!!!!!

 

[Zaffy]

Guys, instead of complaining about how it went, why don't we try to figure out who would have hit LR?

There were 9 minutes between her RC and night. Not to mention just about everyone was hovering over the thread at that point.

It could have been anyone. I agree that we should be looking for scum, but focusing on who had it out for Labby, (or who didn't) won't give us real useful info.

 

[Lady G]

Guys, instead of complaining about how it went, why don't we try to figure out who would have hit LR?

Not sure I'm quite ready to go on another "what if", "who would", "who wouldn't" theory right now!
Personally I think ANYONE playing that is mafia would of hit her, she flat out said she was the DR, they would of been stupid not to put the hit on her