Ice posted the link to the last gunslinger game. I spent some time reading some of it and picked up a few thoughts that made sense looking at this game.
While I realize that they are two completely different games with different players. reading through D1 gave me some reasons to consider given what I have been reading in this game.
JB, you and JP both had LR pegged D1. This was based on I think it was JB's thought that 1 of the people that were scum the previous game could have been scum in that game as well.
While that doesn't happen often, with a random assignment, and the fact that normally you have 25% scum and in this format we have 33% scum, it does lend itself to be more plausible.
The werewolves took you out early too, Libby's students might follow her lead from that game. Was it Pir and Tay?
Here Chill is discussing with me possibilities of who might want me gone early. I have to say that I agreed that it was and is a good possibility. However, I have nothing to go by with Tay as an innocent to make that call. Pir, I think is scarce because of his reunion and trying to learn from the last game.
Sorry Wiz weekends are extremely busy for me so don't know how much I can get on but will try to be here this evening. Right now I have feelings on a couple of players with nothing to substaniate them. I will look to build on those feelings and share them when I get back on. I don't like sharing baseless hunches this early because they may not be right.
Like so many of you he doesn't want to share his hunches w/o anything to back them up. You cannot be lynched in this game and there are no scum hits. Every bit of info helps. But, that's ok too not sharing speaks volumes as well as sharing.
Okay when I said I was watching two players earlier it was Ice and Kash. Dag posted something similar to my concern with Ice - the whole who he might pick if he was mafia - seemed to do nothing but say look I can't be scum cause I would have picked differently.
From the my experince with Kash she seems to dislike these hypotheticals as a waste of time and possible distractions. We know who the scum picked so alternate possabilities don't serve much purpose. I expected her to jump on that yet she says she might pick a noob herself? Seems inconsistent but Wiz you know her better than me so you can mull it over.
Does decide on Ice, the consensus of the town, and Kashta; who as we all know will not post without doing exhaustive research and pulling of posts to back up her ideas and theories.
In general, Chill spent a lot of time with Ice on the posts Ice was making early on. When he did post, there was enough to be considered helpful and vocal.
Going back to how I started this post, Chill, LG, Dawg and Zaffy were my scummates last game. LG at this point looks to be posting as she usually does. I have only played last game w/G as an evil.
Chills posting to this point is reminiscent of last game. Very non commital and just conversational in general.
just a few more thoughts.
