Mafia 78- The Gunslinger Returns...The Play

[rich311k]

You could also be wanting us to distrust Ice so you keep bringing it up. I mentioned it twice I think.

 

[Lady G]

Looking at who is still in the game...
FF
Ice
Pap
Hay
Tay
Rich
JB
Dag
G
JS
Chill=slinger

Taking Chill out as we know he is innocent, assuming Ice is innocent, I personally am not willing to make that Pap is innocent so that would leave us with 9 ppl left.

Knowing Kash was mafia, I really think I have to lower Rich and Tay...I feel that was just to much for distancing of course I could be wrong but I really can't see it when looking back at things.

Leaving, FF, Pap, Hay, JB, Dag, JS I really believe our 4 remaining mafia are in that group of names. Unless of course Pap is mafia, in which case Ice's name needs to go right back in there with the rest.

 

[Lady G]

I don't believe you've been out of line in any way. But the attitude you've revealed in your posting reveals your frame of mind at the time. It's just another clue for us to interpret... not a reference to you or your personality.

This is often a useful indicator which side of the game someone is really on.

The mafia has a very certain win already, Chill being the only one who can change that. Very often in these games, we can see a general cockiness or "attitude" in the mafia's posting when they gain such a clear advantage over the town.

I believe JB was the first say say Tay had a "attitude" or what ever this game. Here, Kash plays on that.

Crap you took your shot....Hope you're right.

I was trying to keep up while driving and I was hoping you'd shoot LG or Tay.

Ice...why were you hoping that? This was before it was revealed what Kashs role was.

This post only goes to prove the point made already about Taysius' attitude in this game. And that's an excellent indication of her role.

Here I'm condemned for misquoting an old game and Taysius takes that further to imply I did that on purpose.

Dear Taysius... thank you for the sweet offer of behalf of ACville choosing me to serve as sole mafia historian of all games. Sadly, I must decline the position as the salary you propose is unsatisfactory. It's neither worth my time nor does it suit my interest. Yours very truly, Kashta.

More about Tay's "attitude"

That's right, Lady G... I'm given a choice between leyting you blow a little thing out of proportiong trying to get Chill to shoot me.... or I answer the questions he asks as he asks them so you can lable me defensive.

Nice plan. You win either way, don't you?

I did happen to win :grinyes:

I just pulled these posts because I think it shows why I feel Tay and Rich have lowered on my list....

That's it, Lady G... keep the focus on me but make sure you work in a disclaimer too in case Chill shoots Rich (your second choice) instead.

With their win so close they can taste it, it only takes one miss now to for them to win this.

Adding what Lady G found? That's her post trying to say it wasn't possible for me to not know which game the mistaken reference was early in a day because I later stopped to look up the title to answer Chill after nightfall that evening.

Lady G is trying to confuse everyone and Taysius is trying to help her.

I find this interesting. Rich maintains that Pappy is scum and lying about his invest clearing Ice as an innocent.

Lady G and Taysius both say they suspect Rich is scummy and should be shot... (as long as Chill shoots me first). However, they've also both decided to give Rich's theory more weight now in such an off-hand way.

Why? Because Chill is going to shoot someone soon and when Rich dies, Chill gets another shot.

Not only did they move Rich down to put me up for shooting instead.. but they're promoting one of their "top" suspect's theory right alongside him.

Classic scum-tell, ladies.

Note, how she says "when Rich dies...Chill gets another shot"...but it was her that got shot, not Rich. I truly believe she thought the last minute "case" would sway Chill to shoot Rich instead, giving the mafia the win. Remember they WOULD of won at that point, had he shot an innocent.

I would like to add also, that it wasn't just then that I say Rich's theory has some merit to it. I mentioned that a LONG time ago, and still maintain the fact Ice and Pap both COULD be mafia. Ice's comment about how he was hoping Chill would shoot me or Tay...took me back a moment there. My very first instinct to that reaction was, OMG ICE and PAP are working together as mafia. Now, I'm not really sure I believe that, but I can't help but think it.

 

[Lady G]

Ok, now my head is going in way to many directions...I am going to get some sleep and come back in the morning.

 

[IceH2O]

Ice...why were you hoping that? This was before it was revealed what Kashs role was.

OMG I thought it was game over.

Glad you went with your gut. After all the bickering today I thought that LG and Tay were just trying to keep the pressure on her.

So now that Kash is dead scum who do we suspect?

I'm still going with those tMy initial instinct is to still go with those that didn't want me shot which would be JB next on the list along with Rich.

I still have a problem with players not wanting LG to get the gun also which would be LG and Tay.

Yeah yeah LG and Tay went hard after Kash today but Chill had been saying she was her shot so it could be distancing.

So my list would be

JB Rich Tay LG


But I only got to skim todays events while driving I want a better read to see who Kash didn't mention today. I just don't know if it would help me decide because Kash and her team could have planned this whole blowup to try to make us think players she named were innocent since it was a good chance that Chill was going to shoot her.

I wasn't in position to get a good read of the days events and what I took from it was that Kash made a good case on you guys using her mistake as the sole reason for her being scum. I was hoping to get back before the shot and get a better read but Chill had to take it earlier so I posted what I thought at the moment.

 

[Chill]

sorry folks I was wiped last night when I got home - tried to read back through but was falling asleep

 

[Chill]

Not sure what I want to ask today but let's start with this:

I know some of you had commented on this all ready but for those who didn't Do you think Kash was going all out for the win or was she trying to ensure the team win by building some cred for her team?

I also don't have a read on Dag. If memory serves I only played with him twice and both times I read him wrong, so if anyone has any thoughts on Dag so far this game can you post them? Sorry Dag not picking on you just trying to be thorough.

 

[Chill]

Yesterday the town was almost unanimous in their suspect list: Kash, Rich, and FF made almost every list. Some scum had to list them so how likely is it that scum would put more than one of their own on a list?

 

[Chill]

Now I have to do some work so will check back later.

 

[Chill]

FF you're very composed this game not only are you not posting all over the place but not one of your posts have given me that stabbing pain in my right eye that you so often do. If you really are changing up your game good for you - the cost might be short term pain for long term gain if it gets you killed but in the long run it's better for you and future towns. If you're being kept on a tight leash by Kash and company bark twice and we'll put you out of your misery.