Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters

[jpappy789]

Ummm she was the kill vote on an innocent

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

i re tracked my vote on the soul of noodles

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

oops u know what i mean

 

[noodles62]

I'm a she
Alright I'm going to explain this the best I can....

I had realized who I think to be a GH before night one, and he gave me the suspicion that UN was also a PR of some sort.Then when UN came out and made kinda RC it solidified what I thought from day 1 and I believed that I knew who two were. When he came out and said that JB wasn't a PR I believed him to be insinuating that JB was scum and he had investigated him. I know he never came out and said all of these things but that is how I was taking it. I never liked the whole weather thing, no point in rehashing it all, and then with the post Lab saying she'd pick JB as a partner. It all seemed to add up as scum to me.

-- I know all of these things aren't exactly as they happened in the thread. Order of posts, what was actually said etc.... But these are my thoughts as to why I voted JB --

I'm sorry I got frustrated. I really really hate being wrong and get extremely frustrated. Call it a complex.

Bally, thank you for explaining this again. I am willing to give you the benefit of the doubt for now - I retract my vote to take Bally's soul.

It would take more time than I have to pull all their posts to show you everything I have worked out this morning. For now... let me begin by introducing my suspicions and attempt to correct some erroneous conclusions we've reached.

I believe Noodles is the murderer.

From the start, Noods expended more effort notifying us about her continual absences and updating us about her computer issues, her work demands, her bleeding husband, and her dire need to fix dinner or vaccuum the carpeting (of all things)... and other nonsense, posting one excuse after another to inform us why she has so little time to play... than anything else. All this to excuse her lack of participation during the earlier part of the game. Within the first (approx.) 250 posts of the thread, she had made only 5. Heck, even the game mod had already posted more than that.

Yes, I'm sure she's been quite busy.... who isn't? Even so, she was also hiding out and keeping a very low profile so we would overlook her.

I picked up on this at the time but have counted her among too many suspects and other side issues which also drew my attention for me to sit back and examine her contribution (?) individually and follow up with this.

Then, at a crucial moment in the game... I also failed notice it was Noods who got us all to make a huge mistake: our misinterpretation of Day 1 nightfall events.

I did not put this all together until a short while ago.

Keeping the final vote count in sequence here as a reminder, she nicely withheld her vote until the end. And these votes, I'll come back to in a moment.



After FF was dead... innocent townie, we read this:



Yes, that was me injecting Lab Rat with Dose #1. I took this writeup to mean it changed her from one side to another. And the final remark "only time will tell" (which was actually a telling clue from the mod) to mean Lady G wasn't going to tell us Labby's role. In fact, what it actually meant was I've got a slow-acting serum.

Lab Rat was not the murderer's first choice as partner from game start as we've thought all this time. (I'll tell you who I believe this is as well... keep reading.)

When nightfall began, Lab Rat was innocent -- right up until the moment I injected her. I was the one who turned Lab Rat evil; not the murderer. (Looking back, she was also probably one of our ghost hunters at this time. The hunch I acted upon to dose her....... more a PR vibe about Lab Rat than her being scum.)

Next came the evil hit. And guess what? The evils (2 of them) also targeted the same person I had just stabbed in the neck --> Lab Rat.

This was evil recruit #2, which according to the rules is a guarantee. 100% result.... claiming the victim to the evil team. This "turn" was not the 50-50 chance later targets would be.

No wonder Lady G had some quick details to work out in a hurry... Lab Rat was both my target (to turn her) and Noodles' newest teammate -- both at the same time.

Here is Nood's initial response after "game on."

Here, Lab Rat died from her injection and her (new) role was revealed.... several minutes after nightfall was over and Day 2 began.

Noodles went on to incriminate Wizard (innocent) for leading the votes against FF (innocent/dead). She nicely included JB (also innocent) in this, which only suggested we suspect him as well.... feeding our concern about the interaction we'd seen between JB and Wizard.... just before she tried to disappear again (back to her scumden).

Before leaving... a quick reaction to Labby's death.

The mod came on to answer our questions about a turn getting killed from an event that can only turn her.

The murderer shows she has heart with a nice comment to consider poor Labby's feelings. But also note what else she managed to work in with this post. She added her "spin" on the events to confuse us into thinking Lab Rat was her 1st turn instead of their 2nd turn.

Asking this question the game mod wasn't going to answer... she lead us to believe Lab was the other turn.

I vote to take the soul of Noodles. She is the murderer.

More to follow about the real Turn #1.

Wow! Kashta you are way off base. I am absolutely not the murderer, but if it takes my lynch to prove that and hopefully help lead us in the right direction then I am ok with that.

In regards to my posts explaining my absence, etc, if you actually think about it, this is something I have always done; when I sign up to play a game I feel guilty about not having enough time to play and I guess it makes me feel better if I explain myself. if it bothers everyone that much I will stop.

 

[Kashta]

I'm sorry folks. I need to double-check other details before I can proceed with what I was going to say. I'm not sure how long this will take, exactly.

Truly, I didn't expect this.

In all fairness to everyone and in the town's best interest, I can't continue yet until I can first make sure I've considered everything that needs to be looked at.

For now: I retract my vote on Noodles.

 

[jpappy789]

I'm...so...confused...

 

[the wizard]

Before I start, let me say I believe Kashta. I too was looking strongly at Noodles for being able to post why she couldn't post but not able to post questions to look like she was kicking bushes.

uuummm, IDK! I would have to consider alot of things; while a vet is a strong team mate, they also could be picked off first due to their experience and threat level. A noob could be a good choice if they have the ability to play along enough but not enough to be called out. As for who I would pick - I dont really want to spend that much time making a decision that is not necessary nor helpful IMO at this point.

Now do your homework like a good boy before you get grounded. :thumbsup:

ok, so earlier posts indicated that you two live in the same house, but yet you have to send him a text? Perhaps you slipped and meant a message in the scum den? Just seems kinda wierd to me! I realize that blended families visit other parents but it is the middle of the week and RL -yesterday both of you stated you were in the same house.....

D1 posts basically taking advantage of the fact that I was pushing to lynch FF.

ok - sorry got sidetracked by a bleeding hubby.....hopefully I can finish my thoughts before he attempts to remove a finger or two while doing his sheet metal work!


FF posted this at 7:12 am







LG posts this at 7:38 am.



I don't know if I am being overly suspicious but this just sticks out to me.... maybe I am reading too much into who was around when LG posted the turn....:huh:

Pointing our attention to the timing of the first turn.

wow. things sure are heating up - got a peeing contest between two hormonal teens and a bunch of spit ball "throwing" pretty much all around. Based on the way things have gone and my initial feelings, I vote to take the soul of FF.

I intended on voting a little while ago but got caught up in RL and then had to get caught up in the game. Oh, and Labby, speaking of popping - picture this = Ball Park Franks (read hot dogs) pop when you cook 'em!
LOL I couldnt resist, my little meat sensitive friend! :rofl:

The final vote on FF, a safe place to be since he was gone anyway.

*sigh* ok, so one was definitely turned and one with unknown results. :wall:

posted after LG posted about LR bieing injected by Kashta.

ATM I am inclined to follow JB onto Wiz. The way he went after him right off, certain that he was scum, then moved off, then moved back - not looking good right now. need to call it a night for now and think about it more tomorrow.......

Another innocent suspected so she places her vote there.

whoa - this outta no where! need to rethink things..........

Reaction to discovering about LR's demise.

I vote to go forward but since Labby is the real victim here I would like to hear how she feels. but wait a minute - so that would mean she was indeed the first turn, right?....hhhmmm.....the wheels on the bus go round and round........

Diplomatic about moving forward even though her plan was foiled by Kashta.

Finally home! :clap: Will look back at a few things before i do my yucky housework/chores...

This exchange between Razz and Rich seems a bit odd to me and maybe even forced?

UN's reply to (chill?) as to why Razz may not have replied as yet...


Altho, not sure why we would want to wait until nightfall?



This seems really odd Rich- not seeing where UN defended Razz, just stated that people are at work....:huh:



Wierd! I dont see where Rich is defending Pappy either....You two care to share what ever it is you are smokin? Hallucinations can be a great alternative when life gets rough!

This just bumped you both up on the scum meter for me!

An attempt to make it look like Rich and Razz are distancing? Razz is the only one from what I can gather suspecting Rich.

Well my best guess is the murderer is probably in this group:
Rich
Hay
Pap
Noods
Ninja
This is based on a series of hunches, guesses, whatever you want to call them and could be completely wrong.

G, I vote for Hay...let me know I need to pull the post.




Well, I know it aint me, I would lean towards Rich and Hay...with Pap and Ninja to follow....

Her response to Chill's list quoted just above again pointing the finger to Rich.

It's pretty obvious to me that she was trying to frame me by naming me (twice in fact as pointed out by Noods). I kept thinking about her vote on Wiz... which is in the end why I didn't keep my vote on him. I believe him to be innocent at this point. I kept pushing my suspicions of him hoping that it would make the scum feel a little less pressured. When Bally came out with her BS post about me being such a good player and coming up with the plan to turn Labby after she made that post, my suspicions on her were confirmed. Which is why I voted her.

Once I'm dead, and you guys know that you can trust what I was saying; look to Bally and Razz. There is still the slim chance that Wiz is evil, but I don't think so atm.

*sigh* I will definately look to Bally and Raz - in the morning. I am tired....This was not a good night - we lost an innocent with the lynch (sorry JB - I was not willing to vote you!) and we dont know the vial results.....

oh, BTW that post by Kashta bothers me....will pull it in the morning; jpap already questioned it.....need to go now.....

Her second post after D2 night fall in response to JB's post just before he was killed off. Again posted just above for context.

wow. The above posts concern me. We lost another innocent in a lynch and we have no idea what the GH results are/were, and the casual, non chalant-ness of the posts above are concerning at the least....

Her response to UN's and Bally's post nightfall events. The time line is very important here. Especially the fact that it was D2.

I forgot to pull something I will continue this in my next post.

 

[the wizard]

Before I started this I sent a message to LG to clarify the rules. If the murderer is turned the scum can no longer turn all they can do is kill. This would explain the write up when Kashta protected herself. They didn't inject her, they pushed her over the rail on the stairs. The result would have been her death. Take note of the part in bold below.

The Ghost Hunters-They do not know each other at game start, but they have the power to investigate to try and find each other. At game start each will send in a name they want investigated, and at each nightfall there after. Investigations will only show "non-Ghost Hunter" or "Ghost Hunter" until they all find each other. As they find one another investigations will be combined. Once they are all known to each other their investigations will show innocent or troubled spirit. If they have found each other by night 4 they will get a seance which will give them a hint. On nights 2 & 4 those able to communicate will be able to "take a soul", choose wisely as you do not want to take an innocent soul, there will be a leader among them that will choose if none are communicating at that time. If the same person is picked by both the GH's and the Murderer, that persons soul will be taken. The Ghost Hunters win, when all the troubled souls are gone.

As I said the timing is important, after night fall on D2 Noods posting has shifted. There still are not a lot of posts, but she has been posting more along the lines of the rest of us. I believe she is trying to help the town.

 

[rich311k]

I am so lost. Does anyone have a script or a drink? Maybe both.

I do not see Noods as scum. I could be wrong but I don't see it. I am leaning more and more towards voting Raz again.

 

[the wizard]

There is a lot to digest today, I understand that however, we only have just under 4 hours until night fall and if I am not mistaken only 3 votes have been placed.

This is not the time for the innocents to be quiet. We need input and discussion to make the best decision for the votes we can.

If Kashta is right and I read every thing correctly, the scum can no longer add to their numbers. All we need to do is locate them and eliminate them. We will not do that by being silent.