Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters

i was thinking about the whole Wiz thing.

I made a very weak and confusing case against JB and kash, a very through and thoughtful player, jumps on board with a very obscure reason of her own. Many vets saw the lack of logic in my post. Why didn't she?
 
kash not wiz sorry
 
jpappy789 said:
That is not what I was referring to. You said in post #1218 that "If the murderer is turned the scum can no longer turn all they can do is kill. This would explain the write up when Kashta protected herself. They didn't inject her, they pushed her over the rail on the stairs. The result would have been her death. Take note of the part in bold below."

The only time the murderer would have been turned was AFTER the hit/turn was attempted in the first place. Therefore you cannot say that LG's write up proves that the murderer was turned N2.

I don't know how else to put this for you.



I cannot choose to not see something I have yet to see in the first place.
Click to expand...

I did not think of the order of events until you brought up the scum attempt was first. That does not negate the fact that the GH vial went through on D2
 
Kashta said:
Of course not, Pappy. And noticing a slip that may hurt the town, and prodding them about it to force them to reveal even more than they already slipped out is not being pro-town either.
Click to expand...

Would voting that player for acting scummy do much better? How about the lingering confusion...does that help the town?
 
JP, you are a very skilled player. I have never known you to skim posts or miss something in the game. I have also never suspected you when you were evil.

That said, because of the exchange we have had,

I vote to take the soul of JP
 
I would like to here better reasons for voting JP than i cant tell when hes evil i for one think he is innocent.
 
jpappy789 said:
Would voting that player for acting scummy do much better? How about the lingering confusion...does that help the town?
Click to expand...

I helped the town as best I could Pappy by giving them the most information I could confirm. I've tried to be as fair and accurate as possible, considering as many angles as well.

If you don't believe that... vote me, turn me, or kill me. It hardly matters which way that goes in my case anymore.
 
To further explain my vote, you are an excellent turn candidate as you can switch teams with out revealing it in the game thread.

I believe that the only reason you never suspected Noods is because you have been communicating with her.
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom