Mafia 80: Ghost Hunters

[jpappy789]

No, that is what I've been trying to say the whole time. Just think about it logically. You say that if I did go to Bally others might have followed.. How would I know that?

Sorry Hay, but that isn't what you've been saying.

You've been saying that you would have been killed, several times, despite the vote counts stating otherwise.

 

[Haydn24]

Jp, stop twisting crap around. Read through last night again and you will see I didn't even think of voting for Bally until it was too late or even after night fall.

 

[the wizard]

Highly likely he is murderer? Based on what?

Maybe you are Bally's teammate.

Voting based on what could happen is worse than what might have happened based on evidence. I feel we are at the point in the game where you should be looking at actual posts.

I colored the question to make it easier for you to see.

Pappy, I said "highly possible" not highly likely. Stop twisting words.

This post does not answer JP's post above. It addresses it but it does not answer it.

I kind of would be interested in hearing how you would answer this. What is your evidence that he is the murderer?

The rest of us, except for the DR on D1 hasn't been able to nail down 1 scum and you have the murderer? I am all ears.

 

[jpappy789]

Jp, stop twisting crap around. Read through last night again and you will see I didn't even think of voting for Bally until it was too late or even after night fall.

Then show me where...apparently I cannot read.

 

[the wizard]

No, that is what I've been trying to say the whole time. Just think about it logically. You say that if I did go to Bally others might have followed.. How would I know that?

You have stated that basically without a doubt, you would have died even though you weren't in danger of that when you placed your vote. How would you know that?

 

[Kashta]

If this is true then it should tell us a couple of things.

Kash if you are not communicating and your RC is true then the hit was on your protection and you should tell us who that was because the evil all ready know who they tried to hit. I'll understand if you want to wait for G's confirmation.

GH's if Kash is not in communication with you then it is unlikely that she was vialed. That information by it's self doesn't tell us much other than she wasn't vialed but it's worth considering.

I truly understand the dilemma. You still have to figure me into this.... maybe it will help for me to write this out.

1. Murderer - Can't be me. No one can be both the Doctor and the Murderer at the same time.

2. 1st pick Day 1 - This was their only chance to get me so far.

But to believe this, you'd also have to believe the evils would turn me one day...... then turn AND dose Lab Rat the next....... when they only get a 50-50 chance at subsequent turns. They couldn't have guessed Lab Rat would die that same night and be revealed by the game mod in error.

A successful Lab Rat turn wasn't supposed to reveal her name and role to us. Just that "someone unknown" got turned without telling us who it was....... and that "someone unknown" got dosed and turned (not killed) without telling us who that was either. Nobody would have known the hit attempt and the dose victim were the same person.

Why would I (as evil) turn someone to my side and dose her at the same time on purpose knowing the town wouldn't find out it was her? That'd be stupid. We'd end up turning our own turn back to innocent again. I couldn't guess Lady G was going to kill her by mistake and reveal her role to the town instead of turning her a full day before this happened.

3. Night 1 Evil Turn - Wasn't me. Lab Rat was their hit and I dosed her the same night. Her name/role was revealed and she died by mistake.

4. Night 2 GH Turn - Wasn't me. I don't know who this was, ask User Name.

5. Night 3 Turn? - There wasn't one. No one got turned.

 

[Haydn24]

Yes I doubt you now. The way you acted before nightfall caught my attention. You jumped on me after voting for razz, why? Did you know she was innocent?

Jp, this is where I pointed out Bally. Note the now bit. This was after nightfall.

 

[Ninja Pigs Rock]

noodles im not going to say anything except that ur wrong and everyone thinks so to.

 

[Kashta]

Everyone must be working or learning today.

Right now I see no reason to doubt UN and I am not sure what to think of Kashta, I am tending to beleive her since there was no sign of a turn in the night fall. The fact that she did not use the vial makes me wonder if her whole claim is true or not. She has a short list of suspects but could not find a target. Just makes me wonder a bit.

Bally is my other concern. She did the classic I made mistake just kill me defense and I have not seen all that from her since to really think she is anything but scum. She did push for Jb's lynch, based on her interpretation of the rules which was clearly incorrect.

I had too many targets, Rich. Any one of them I picked was just as likely to be a ghost hunter instead of scum.

 

[the wizard]

Noods, I guess I was way off base with you when I was posting yesterday. I saw a couple of posts that looked like you were changing direction but when a straight question is put to you you cannot answer it. I guess the "sigh" I noticed the second time you posted it wasn't in relation to being turned innocent, rather it looks like it was frustration at having to appear innocent.