Ok, maybe you didn't say he was evil...but can you answer why you said you thought he was being defensive in the post, because you were the only one who had questioned him at that point, when in fact 2 others had and that was pointed out to you?
Mafia 87: The Play, Basic Game
- Thread starter Fishfriend1
- Start date
I see why you thought I meant PR's, but I didn't. I worded it incorrectly. As I have stated before (not about this specific post) is that I suspected either UN or NPR/LG as scum, but I knew one was wrong. They didn't act like team mates.
I meant I knew either UN or LG/NPR were innocent.
Ok, sorry, but that's a bunch of baloney. Really, if I were scum with Tank, I wouldn't have touched him with a 10-foot pole. I didn't want him to UD because he did vote (in the wrong way, yes) and a UD can bring down a game. If he were an innocent, that would have been just another step closer to the scum team. And I wasn't the only one who didn't want him to be UD'd...
I just can't win, can I? If I switch votes around, I'm scum. If I vote late, I'm scum. And it's not like I said 1 thing about UN... there were multiple posts not in his favor. I wanted to see if something else would come up. I men, UN would have been lynched either way.
If I had to pick a scum team, I'd probably say LG, NPR, (Zaffy?). Not sure for the 3rd one, but Zaffy and LG have some major agreeing going on, and LG was super-defensive of NPR. So that's my best guess. 2H's defense was BS, but not really scummy.
My vote wouldn't have effected UN getting lynched. Your vote was completely out of nowhere and for no reason. (!)
I know I just posted that you weren't scummy, but I'm starting to rethink that. Seems awfully easy for a scum to just put a random vote out there that everyone will overlook... No messing around.
Sorry I can't multi quote cause I'm on my itouch. But to answer your question if you look back in the thread if you don't SKIM then you will see I stated that we learn nothing from trians and bally still seemed scummy to me so I left my vote the way it was. And depending on the events that occur in day 2 I may just vote the same way again.
Pir besides the fact that lg agreed with me why do you see me as scum? In a arguement there are 2-3 sides and you have to pick one and lg took mine. If your gonna call scum like this the bally un and 2H are all scum as well, at least by your standards. So I don't see you reasoning very valid and well thought out. Also sorry to see you go dwag.
Never said you were the only one that didn't want the UD to go through, UN also said something (I believe the first)...but the way you put it..ya looked awfully worried about him UDing. Yes, I know a UD can effect a game...but it is part of the game. We can't go changing the rules mid game just to suit others, if we did that we may as well have no rules at all.
I do agree there were multiple posts about UN, by yourself and by others. My point is it does not look good in any way the way you waited until the end to put your vote there. To me it looks like you started a case on UN, then waited to see where it went, once it got going then you vote kinda "sealing the deal". UN looked bad no matter what, and yes he most likely was going rather you put your vote there or on someone else, but you can't say your vote would not of effected the outcome, these game can change fast...had you voted else where you never know what would of happened.
At this point, until I see answers from Ninja and Bally
I retract my vote on Pir
Ok, I see you answered while I was typing. I see what you are saying and have done that myself several times, thank you for the answer.
Missed Hay's post in all the crap with UN.
You are correct, I see that Hay and UN both questioned him about it.
Zaff and I have some major agreeing? Really?
I wasn't really defending Ninja, my vote for UN really had nothing to do with Ninja it was his scum den comments that got my vote. As I said before, the whole Ninja thing was more I didn't see where he was so defensive and asked those who said he was what they saw as defensive. They wouldn't answer me just kept adding the one post, not really saying what about it was scummy...except for Bally, who's answer had false statements in it.
