Mafia #90-The Split

[Fishfriend1]

Woops, my bad. The 2nd quote isn't supposed to be there.

 

[[AC] gold leader]

did I really put noods? Man, I really am out of it... that's what i get for staying up late for 4 days in a row... yes, Noods=Bally.

You did not say that you were sure that Bally was evil, but you, by attacking her so fiercely, have pretty much made it clear where you stand with her. I do not know Bally's role, but from what i've seen she made a dumb mistake, voted early, and then did a bad job at correcting her mistake. On your part, you jumped on her jumping on GL (why, I have no idea) and for making a few mistakes. While i do not think for sure that Bally is innocent, right now I think you are the scummier.

I vote to lynch Gold_Leader because I truly do think that Bally kicked the wrong bush here, and is now being attacked by the snake living under it.

Just to keep my scorecard straight... you think Star is scummier than Bally but your vote lands on me? K... right.

Where's the asprin?

 

[[AC] Star-Crossed]

did I really put noods? Man, I really am out of it... that's what i get for staying up late for 4 days in a row... yes, Noods=Bally.

You did not say that you were sure that Bally was evil, but you, by attacking her so fiercely, have pretty much made it clear where you stand with her. I do not know Bally's role, but from what i've seen she made a dumb mistake, voted early, and then did a bad job at correcting her mistake. On your part, you jumped on her jumping on GL (why, I have no idea) and for making a few mistakes. While i do not think for sure that Bally is innocent, right now I think you are the scummier.

I vote to lynch Gold_Leader because I truly do think that Bally kicked the wrong bush here, and is now being attacked by the snake living under it.

Someone has to do the work in this game, building cases on people who look scummy and trying to sort out who is scum from who is townie. Would you rather I sit back and not jump on things that strike me as scummy?

Also, what did Bally do a good job on correcting? Did you fail to notice that she admitted to skimming the very post she used for her reason for voting for GL? That she failed to retract her vote, even knowing nightfall wasn't until tomorrow night.

You say she kicked the wrong bush, what bush was that? Throwing a vote on someone whose post she didn't even bother to read?

 

[[AC] HI IQ]

Rum is disgusting.

If you're a pirate. Are you a pirate, Rich?

Does your pm from LG say something about Zaffy's boxers?

That brown streak is a gift? eeewwwwww...


On another note... I hope Bala's hungry.

LG... do you plan to reveal the roles of the UDs?

This is not 'Nam, dude. This is mafia. There are rules.

Geez. Hope everything's ok guys. Still though, nothing like making the game neigh on impossible to win. And only 24 hours after the start too.

Of course it bothers me. How could it not? Four townies are dead, including 2 prs and a good player, and the scumbags didn't have to lift a finger. And yes, I also believe that there was no choice but to go by the stated rules. The two are not mutually exclusive.

It's always nice to get a vote, but I have a coupla little questions; if I may.

1. Nightfall isn't until tomorrow night, so what has tonight's final got to do with anything?
2. Nonchalant about rules are rules... WTF?... these games have rules for a reason. If we go changing them willy-nilly just because we feel like it, then there's no need for them at all. I hate to sound like RB, but there is no other way than to follow the rules once posted. LG went further than I would have by extending the deadline for the UDs.
3. Unless my kindergarten math skills have totally left me, 4 people UD'd, not three.
4. You didn't bold your vote.

Anything else?

I was busily posting while you fixed it. Why stick with a BS vote even though now you know you'll be here for nightfall? Interesting to me that Rich starts out pointing a general finger, and you come in and follow it up with a vote which you're now "more confident" about. Be confident all you want, it won't make you right. I actually agree with Star here... I'm picking up the slightest hint of scum. Time to stand up wind.

I'd still like to get an answer to my question: IE: why do you feel the need to vote so early when you now know you'll be around for nightfall? Especially to go so far as to say you're feeling confident in your vote with so little to go on from anyone?

What do you call it? Looks like two lines to me. I just don't see where you're coming from here, Bally.

:rofl: But you're viewing on your phone. The lines are only about an inch wide.

I'm tempted to place my vote now, but I don't want to jump the gun. I'd really like to hear from more countries what they think of this little exchange.

Uh-Oh... a glitch in the matrix!

Ok, FF... I can see where you're coming from. But indulge me:

What do you think of the fact that Rich floated the finger pointing at me then Bally jumped on it.
What do you think of the fact that Bally didn't know how many innocents UDed? (which suggests that she not only skimmed my post, but LG's post as well)
What do you think of the fact that with so little to go on Bally felt the need to put a vote out there, despite the fact that a bad lynch is BAD for the town at this point?

I don't think Star followed me at all. We were seeing the same things at the same time and commented on it. If we were on the same team, do you really think that we would have come out with a coordinated Death Star type attack? Seems pretty far fetched to me. You say that Bally thought tonight was nightfall, but she herself corrected that mistake and still kept up with a BS vote that she says she's "confident" about. I'm not buying what you're selling Jr.

I'm really interested in your answer to Zaffy.

When you hear hoofbeats, I bet you think zebra.

Let's see...typical day one chit chat....

An arguement about lines in a screen....

And some generic finger pointing....


Pretty self centered to indirectly deem your posts are "real" and others are "skirting"....



Chill.

 

[Dangerdoll]

I really wouldn't consider her not retracting her post immediately as scum tell..... she has the option to change her vote any time before night fall..... so I am failing to see why that would be an obvious thing.

 

[[AC] gold leader]

Let's see...typical day one chit chat....

An arguement about lines in a screen....

And some generic finger pointing....


Pretty self centered to indirectly deem your posts are "real" and others are "skirting"....



Chill.

Wow... you're making some assumptions there, dude. Just trying to get people talking now that there's something to talk about. I think it's strange when people just gloss over actual talking points. Especially on day 1.

But by all means, keep your panties bunched.

 

[Fishfriend1]

Just to keep my scorecard straight... you think Star is scummier than Bally but your vote lands on me? K... right.

Where's the asprin?

I think that you are the don. When star went beserk over Bally's post, it was because bally voted YOU, not Star. Therefor, if you ARE the don, your teammate, Star simply overeacted to the vote on you. That's what I'm seeing.

What your seeing is that Bally voted someone for admittedly less then perfect reasons and you and Star both jumped on it. I can see that argument too. What keeps me away from it is how you and Star were so coordinated and in synce with each other, IMO.

Asprins are in the kitchen, behind my ADHD meds... lol

Someone has to do the work in this game, building cases on people who look scummy and trying to sort out who is scum from who is townie. Would you rather I sit back and not jump on things that strike me as scummy?

Also, what did Bally do a good job on correcting? Did you fail to notice that she admitted to skimming the very post she used for her reason for voting for GL? That she failed to retract her vote, even knowing nightfall wasn't until tomorrow night.

You say she kicked the wrong bush, what bush was that? Throwing a vote on someone whose post she didn't even bother to read?

Of course not, I never said not to kick bushes and stuff, but you seem to have become tunnel visioned on Bally.

Where did I say bally did a good job correcting anything? The post says quite clearly that she did a BAD job in correcting herself. Never do i say she did a good job at it. So, where did that come from?

She voted GL. You leaped on her for it. She may not have intentionally kicked the bush, but she did, and now the snakes are coming out to get her for disturbing them.

Let's see...typical day one chit chat....

An arguement about lines in a screen....

And some generic finger pointing....

Pretty self centered to indirectly deem your posts are "real" and others are "skirting"....

Chill.

What do you think about the whole "They could be teammates" thing? (they being Gold and Star)

 

[[AC] Star-Crossed]

I really wouldn't consider her not retracting her post immediately as scum tell..... she has the option to change her vote any time before night fall..... so I am failing to see why that would be an obvious thing.

Not so much that the lack of an immediate retraction is scummy, but that along with everything else that has gone on is why I am voting for her. She totally admitted she didn't read the post that she is using as her reason for voting for GL. How can you legitimately place a vote in the best interest of the town when you don't even read what the person you are voting for as scum has posted? With the loss of 4 innocents before night 1, we can't afford to be sloppy. I'd think anyone who wants the town to win would carefully evaluate all posts put forth before just throwing a vote out there. My vote was not carelessly placed and Bally still strikes me as most scummy so far. FF is rapidly rising as scum too. This is a WIFOM question, but if Bally were don, do you think she would pick FF as a possible teammate? Or would FF, if don, pick Bally as a possible teammate?

 

[[AC] Star-Crossed]

Of course not, I never said not to kick bushes and stuff, but you seem to have become tunnel visioned on Bally.

Where did I say bally did a good job correcting anything? The post says quite clearly that she did a BAD job in correcting herself. Never do i say she did a good job at it. So, where did that come from?

She voted GL. You leaped on her for it. She may not have intentionally kicked the bush, but she did, and now the snakes are coming out to get her for disturbing them.

Not tunnel visioned, you are also in my sight. For all I know, GL could be scum too. All I know is my role. And yes, I meant bad job of correcting, so what did she even try to correct? I saw a bunch of excuses then a final admittance that she couldn't even be bothered to read the post that she decided to vote for GL over. I did not leap on her for voting GL. I leapt on her for voting for a post she admitted to not even reading, for not even bothering to read we were down 4 innocents, for saying we were only down 3 innocents, for already throwing excuses out there, and for not providing any satisfactory answers to any of my questions that would make me think she was less scummy. It didn't matter to me that it was GL she voted for for the crappy reasons, if it had been anyone I would still think her methods and reasoning were scummy.

 

[rich311k]

Bally - Do you really think we were going to bo convinced that was such a long post you did not have time to read it? You sure jumped on my question awfully quickly. I was just fishing.