Mafia 93: Tank of Terror! Freshwater Version

RazzleFish said:
I agree with you that UN doesn't seem as likely to be scum after that but that does not excuse his scummy posts. The mafia being willing to take that big of a risk on Day 1 does sound unlikely though.

We also have to take into account that the scum team still has one more hit that they now get to use on whoever they want. The rules are the same as when they were posted in the signup so there may only be 3 members of the mafia team which makes more sense to me. If there are 4 people on the mafia team, odds that the town would win were never good to begin with.
Click to expand...
Would it of not been a bigger risk to move, knowing AAF would turn innocent?
 
Zaffy said:
Again, you analysis of DD feels like it comes from a vets perspective.

It seems to me like you may have some coaching.
Click to expand...
It doesn't take a vet to do that analysis. The first part was just reiterating what labby said, the second part was just saying the way that I portrayed aaf and saw how DD could have gotten mixed up.
 
Lady G said:
Would it of not been a bigger risk to move, knowing AAF would turn innocent?
Click to expand...

Lose a mafia player through a lynch Day1 or lose a mafia player through a lynch Day 2. Neither are good for the mafia but they don't seem all that different IMO. Is there something I'm overlooking?
 
You know what, I'm not feeling so comfortable with my vote on Doll at the moment. I agree with Zaff, there is something not sitting right with me on Labs posts. Lab, you have pretty much just chimed in on others posts, and not really put much out there of your own thoughts, very short posts except your post "clearing" UN.

I retract my vote on Doll and vote to lynch Lab
 
rich311k said:
I think we need to look past whether a new player is couched or not. I think it may be being brought up to distract us from looking for real mafia.
Click to expand...
LOL, or COACHED even ;)
 
RazzleFish said:
Lose a mafia player through a lynch Day1 or lose a mafia player through a lynch Day 2. Neither are good for the mafia but they don't seem all that different IMO. Is there something I'm overlooking?
Click to expand...
It was 50/50 always a chance their mate would not be lynched, taking the chance and then "clearing" them because of it sounds way better to me. I have no idea if that is what happened but to me yes, it makes since, plus if UN had been lynched and turned scum those on him would be "cleared" at least for a while. Although, I'm not sure I see UN as scum at this point..still just because there were no moves, does NOT clear him in my mind.
 
Lady G said:
It was 50/50 always a chance their mate would not be lynched, taking the chance and then "clearing" them because of it sounds way better to me. I have no idea if that is what happened but to me yes, it makes since, plus if UN had been lynched and turned scum those on him would be "cleared" at least for a while. Although, I'm not sure I see UN as scum at this point..still just because there were no moves, does NOT clear him in my mind.
Click to expand...

I guess that's understandable. I'm not clearing him by any means I just feel that risking lynching him on Day 1 makes him seem less likely to be scum.
 
RazzleFish said:
I'm not sure I'd call it vet standards quite yet but definatly not first game play.

What I find odd is that GSM has 17 or so posts total, only 5 since nightfall, and of those 5 the only one that says anything is just a summary of what Lab said. So GSM so you have any original thoughts about DD's game play? Or anyone else's play?
Click to expand...

Care to answer my questions GSM?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom