Mafia 95 - "Mayor's Mansion" (The Play)

[mostlycichlids]

Even for a Day 2, a higher number player game gets really hard to get a scum..just an opinion. Especially if the Mod went to the lower side of a 25/75 split, which isn't uncommon with limited town PRs.


Mad, your comments do make me somewaht reconsider Wiz's comments over post 707/713 with chill....

I agree, I guess I didn't read into it enough to see that Wiz had made that many risky comments (risky to himself).

Paul's random vote for Labby also kind of reminds me of how he played scum in Mafia 46. I was C-note that game.

It was a random vote on day one and that was it, I wasnt sure if I would have time to be back sense I had a death in the family and I did not want to UD.

Only thing about that would be if she was forcing a tie..but that will go out the window if spence shows innocent on a lynch or being compassionate. And we know that isn't true over her banning tactics in general..lmao.

That's my logic, in the games I played in the past it seems like the mafia play both cards and try to hide in their voting. Yes I did also vote spence but I was also one who did not vote FF when most everyone else was so convinced he was mafia. IMO there were really no other suspects on my list at the time. Now I am thinking mafia is confortable with their vote and are being quiet and didnt care either way if it was spence or FF.

Voting FF would have been a much easier way to save spencer...I'm not sure how you can save anyone by making it a 50% chance they will die...

But jpapp, it would also of been much more obvious being she was one of the last to vote. I guess at the same time if spence would of been killed and innocent would of been more obvious. I see where you are coming from in a way I guess.

 

[the wizard]

Paul's random vote for Labby also kind of reminds me of how he played scum in Mafia 46. I was C-note that game.

Did he usually play as he is this time? Or would the lack of input possibly be a scum tell on him?

 

[jpappy789]

MC's theory isn't logical. When DD voted Spence, it was 8-7 FF in the lead. DD then tied it up at 8 leaving Pir and Chill as the only 2 left to vote.

So you are saying what here?

That MC is trying to get us to look at DD?

I am having a little trouble following why he would say she voted Spence to save Spence.

Could you answer this question for us MC?

If that is the case my best guess is that MC picked DD because her name was on the block. A few, like yourself, have mentioned things recently like the scum were okay with the lynching therefore spencer might be innocent. DD would be the next logical choice to push based on last night's vote count.

I'd like MC to clarify his theory before assuming so...

 

[the wizard]

If that is the case my best guess is that MC picked DD because her name was on the block. A few, like yourself, have mentioned things recently like the scum were okay with the lynching therefore spencer might be innocent. DD would be the next logical choice to push based on last night's vote count.

I'd like MC to clarify his theory before assuming so...

In light of this, I would also need to rethink my stand on DD.

 

[mostlycichlids]

MC's theory isn't logical. When DD voted Spence, it was 8-7 FF in the lead. DD then tied it up at 8 leaving Pir and Chill as the only 2 left to vote.

So you are saying what here?

That MC is trying to get us to look at DD?

I am having a little trouble following why he would say she voted Spence to save Spence.

Could you answer this question for us MC?

I have already explained my reasoning a few times. It seems like rb is kind of understanding as well, but in any case It seems more so like a way to lay low, under the radar.

 

[jpappy789]

I agree, I guess I didn't read into it enough to see that Wiz had made that many risky comments (risky to himself).

It was a random vote on day one and that was it, I wasnt sure if I would have time to be back sense I had a death in the family and I did not want to UD.

That's my logic, in the games I played in the past it seems like the mafia play both cards and try to hide in their voting. Yes I did also vote spence but I was also one who did not vote FF when most everyone else was so convinced he was mafia. IMO there were really no other suspects on my list at the time. Now I am thinking mafia is confortable with their vote and are being quiet and didnt care either way if it was spence or FF.

But jpapp, it would also of been much more obvious being she was one of the last to vote. I guess at the same time if spence would of been killed and innocent would of been more obvious. I see where you are coming from in a way I guess.

MC, how can you say that "most everyone was convinced [FF] was mafia" and then turn around and say that DD would be obvious in voting FF? Looking back FF's antics certainly gave mafia a good place to hide if they wanted to...

FF was in the lead before DD voted. Had she tacked one on at the end or voted any other person then spencer would have had much lower chance of getting lynched, certainly less than 50%.

 

[Madcrawdad]

Did he usually play as he is this time? Or would the lack of input possibly be a scum tell on him?

Paul's involvement thus far is pretty much what I'd expect, regardless of alignment...

Wiz, any comments on my post #876?

 

[mostlycichlids]

Did he usually play as he is this time? Or would the lack of input possibly be a scum tell on him?

You could always go back and browse that game... I am just saying...what do you mean by lack of input?

 

[Lab_Rat]

I think I understand what Wiz was getting at yesterday with it being too quiet and scum were happy, for I had that same feeling. I still felt the need to vote my best suspect so I left my vote where it was. So far Wiz appears to be working hard for the town from what I can tell. What I find interesting is the tag team against him from Mad and RB.

 

[Madcrawdad]

I think I understand what Wiz was getting at yesterday with it being too quiet and scum were happy, for I had that same feeling. I still felt the need to vote my best suspect so I left my vote where it was. So far Wiz appears to be working hard for the town from what I can tell. What I find interesting is the tag team against him from Mad and RB.

Tag team? You really think RB is pushing Wiz? Why'd you leave NPR out? IMO he's said more about Wiz than RB.