Mafia #99: The ACville Files- Game Thread

[dundadundun]

alright... all caught up.

i think i'm going to have to agree with this...

This is a numbers game, you very well know that. It's stupid to not save a teammate from a coin flip if you can possibly do so without arising suspicion. I don't see why you think they wouldn't make a couple easy, unsuspicious moves to keep him from a coin toss.

I vote to send Ice to the loony bin. He's not making sense.

dunno about "unsuspicious" moves, though. seems any move can be suspicious at any time, really.

i vote to send ice to the loony bin.

now to get back to making dinner....

 

[dirtydawg10]

Ah, nvm. lol.

 

[the wizard]

I won't be home for night fall, I won't be home this afternoon, going to a friends watching the Saints/SF game, not sure yet who I'm pulling for but expect the Saints will win. I plan on being very drunk so I won't be able to drive home right after the game ends.

I retract my vote on FF and vote to send Wiz to the looney bin

I don't like how he seems discombobulated this game,he either isn't into it or is trying to figure a way out of the mess he put his team into. There aren't that many posts that he shouldn't be able to follow the game but it seems he is skimming posts and giving answers that don't coincide with those posts.

Exactly what "mess" did I put my "team" into. My comments were about you voting so quickly over FF's slip when I have seen you require more than that to convince you he was scum. You yourself admitted partly it was due to another thread. You then state that I am defending FF?

I don't see the defense of FF in my posts. You sir are either misguided or scum. Knowing that you won't be back prior to night fall creates a pickle for me as I would like to hear explanation and with out such I can't bring myself to vote for you as I would never OMGUS vote anyone.

The fact that you drew your vote off of FF so easily after stating how convinced you were makes me wonder if maybe you two are team mates and we already know that you don't have an issue with throwing team mates under the bus.

 

[Lab_Rat]

dunno about "unsuspicious" moves, though. seems any move can be suspicious at any time, really.

True, but Ice is a master at this game. He knows very well how moves can be made without drawing much attention, especially early in the game. Look how spread out the votes were. It would have been easy to consolidate some of those votes without being suspicious. How many day 1 votes do you see that remain totally spread out? Not many iirc.

 

[noodles62]

Exactly what "mess" did I put my "team" into. My comments were about you voting so quickly over FF's slip when I have seen you require more than that to convince you he was scum. You yourself admitted partly it was due to another thread. You then state that I am defending FF?

I don't see the defense of FF in my posts. You sir are either misguided or scum. Knowing that you won't be back prior to night fall creates a pickle for me as I would like to hear explanation and with out such I can't bring myself to vote for you as I would never OMGUS vote anyone.

The fact that you drew your vote off of FF so easily after stating how convinced you were makes me wonder if maybe you two are team mates and we already know that you don't have an issue with throwing team mates under the bus.

This is what I am talking about. So if FF flips scum we have a pretty good idea where to vote next.

 

[Kashta]

relax, Kash.... you shouldn't be taking the vote so personally. With such little going on, it's the best I had to vote for. Why on earth are you so bent up over one measily vote?

DD, you are either scum or you're totally not paying attention. I wasn't concerned about the vote. Getting a single vote or several votes doesn't bother me. What caught my attention was the reason you gave..... because my post was "off." Plus, not even trying to explain what that's supposed to mean. My post was "off".... in what way? My post was "off" .... okay well, compared to what? The way I post when I'm evil? The way I post when I do by phone from work..... or whatever else.

I've asked you to explain what you meant by that but you still haven't done so.

Had you voted me for some random thing or a joke thing, I wouldn't have questioned it. Just, to toss somebody's name out there for no actual reason and not just randomly... and saying something as vague and meaningless as their first post is "off" tells me you want that person to "appear" suspicious..... but for no reason. Later in the game, you or your teammates can just build off that to fabricate a case against someone who isn't evil.

Case in point: Now, instead of simply explaining what you really meant by "off" (which wasn't a difficult question) ..... you dodged the question. Then you went further.... saying I'm overreacting because I got a vote.

One more time, it wasn't the vote I questioned. It was the lame, non-reason you gave for it.

Another case in point: Dawg has voted me and gave an actual reason. I don't have a problem with his vote or his reason. At this stage of the game, a reason like that is about as good as another. The difference between Dawg's vote and your vote is that Dawg didn't add on some flimsy BS veneer of suspicion to it by making the suggestion that my game or my posting is.... "off" in some unspecified manner that he won't explain.

I vote to send DD to the looney bin. That's where she belongs.

 

[Kashta]

FF, thanks for clarifying your statement. Also, with as spread out as the votes were, and going into nightfall with a tie, if FF was scum I don't see his teammates not moving to save him. There was plenty of time to do so in a subtle way.

They could have made something up then claimed they didn't realize it was a tie. I'm sure there's many excuses scum could have used to vote LG and save FF if they were so inclined.

Can't say I agree. Even knowing it meant the scum would be down 1 member, I could see a number of possible scum players letting him go just to keep the scum team's game plan simple and uncomplicated. I've been scum with FF before and I used to work at trying to help him along. I seriously doubt I would have the patience to do that anymore. Although, I'm sure a lot depends on who the other scum members are.

 

[noodles62]

Day 2:

FF- Dawg 101, Ice 103, Noods 170
Wiz- Ice 154
Dun- JB 155
Kash- Dawg 160
Ice- Lab 166, AAF 169
Kash- DD 172

No votes from: FF, Bally, UN, Zaffy, Wiz, Kash, Dun

Nightfall in 2 hours.

Well, I do not want to leave my vote on a UD. It is unusual for FF to UD but I will check back in a while and move my vote if needed.

 

[Kashta]

I don't know about Dawg or Ice, it seems like they're trying to get inside FF's head. That's a one way trip to crazy town.
JB makes me wonder too, his vote fell on FF yesterday, and today he's playing devils advocate for him.

as far as FF, He's planted his foot so firmly in his mouth so many times I'm not really sure what to think about his alleged slip.

This post strikes me as saying almost nothing whatsoever.

 

[Lab_Rat]

Can't say I agree. Even knowing it meant the scum would be down 1 member, I could see a number of possible scum players letting him go just to keep the scum team's game plan simple and uncomplicated. I've been scum with FF before and I used to work at trying to help him along. I seriously doubt I would have the patience to do that anymore. Although, I'm sure a lot depends on who the other scum members are.

I think it depends on who is on the scum team. Personally, I would try to save my teammates if I possibly could, no matter how irritated I was, as long as I could do so without attracting attention. Ice is one who would let FF get lynched, and possibly even help get him lynched, to make himself look good. Therefore, if Ice flips scum it in no way clears FF. I am fine with where my vote is right now, Ice seems scummier to me than FF does at this point.