Osmocote as fert?

This is the one I use: 19-6-12 as it has no copper.

Osmocote-Outdoor-Indoor-Smart-Release-Plant-Food-std.jpg





  • Available in water resistent bottles of 1.25 lb. and 3 lb. and in a re-sealable 10 lb. bag.
 
Dundadundun - I believe you were the one that suggested it to me. Seemed too easy to be true, but I searched on here and it seems quite common.

I have regular gravel in my 10g and small pebble gravel in the 55g. I just ordered a plant package and started freaking out when I received the package - totally overwhelmed.

I am the farthest thing from a DIYer so Osmocote sounds like the path for me. I am going to have a go with DIY CO2 though... :eek3:
it is almost too easy to be true. fear not though... you still have to not overfill your cube tray so they'll go under your substrate without issues and get them under before they melt.

What's the downside to using only osmocote?
can't control it. urea overload. tank full of dead fish. algae everywhere.

all possibilities...

dry ferts are easily controlled. good for the water column.

EDIT: that's also the one i have i think.
 
How much do you use? One cube under each plant.
works for me so far. i suppose a huge plant with lots of roots could use more.
 
If you do use Osmocote make sure you do it right, don't just mix it into the substrate.

I made a noob mistake and mixed Osmocote into my substrate, and some of the granules were left at or very near the surface. This caused 2 problems.

The first was that ammonia skyrocketed out of control for several days and killed some of my fish. Even doing daily water changes, a couple got sick and died. After a few days the ammonia levels stabilized. I don't know if it is because the bacteria and/or plants adjusted to consume more ammonia or if the osmocote just releases its fertilizer way faster in the first few days. I think it's the latter, since I have read other people say the same thing, that it releases about 50% of its total content within the first 72 hours or so and the rest is released slower.

The second is that over time, the granules become buoyant somehow and can float around. I was picking Osmocote spheres out of the foiliage of my anacharis and other plants constantly. Very annoying.

P.S. - Just something I found interesting, I remember someone on these forums was saying that the Osmocote spheres are capsules that contain liquid fertilizer. This is not true, but I understand how they might get that wrong impression. The Osmocote beads are actually solid, dry fertilizer, coated with whatever coating they use to make them slow-release. If you break one open, it's hard inside like candy or something. However, after they have been in your tank for a while, the water penetrates the inside and eventually dissolves the solid fertilizer stuff inside, so if you pick up a bead that has been in your tank for a while and smash it, the thin outer "shell" will pop and you'll see the inside will be filled with white liquid. They don't start out liquid inside though. Just wanted to clear that up :)
 
Try this:
http://www.bobstropicalplants.com/shop/en/6-fertilizers
It's cheap and goes a long way :) I think he can ship it first class mail, too.

I know you are worried, but honestly I'm 100% sure it's fine if you use it properly. (Probably not safe to dump a ton in your tank at once, but why would you? A couple of tabs under the substrate of each heavy feeder should not hurt a thing.)

You started this thread almost 2 years ago...you still haven't tried it? ;)
 
AquariaCentral.com