will firefish and purple firefish co-exist?

[vt_snowman87]

will these two live peacefully with 1 of each? any experience?

 

[jojo22]

Should be fine IME!!

 

[Pallen81]

a week ago or so I posted a question asking if Firefish were a shoaling fish or should be kept singly. Overhelmingly, people favored schools for Firefish. But every book I've read says otherwise... for example.

from the book "Marine Fishes - 500 essential species to know"
Firefish are best kept singly, unless the tank is very large or a male-female pair is obtained. Purple Firefish are the most aggressive of the firefish family and should be housed as the only Firefish in a system.

I also have another book that states this same opinion. So, I guess its up to you. I just wanted you to be confused like me! :eek3:

 

[5xevy]

a week ago or so I posted a question asking if Firefish were a shoaling fish or should be kept singly. Overhelmingly, people favored schools for Firefish. But every book I've read says otherwise... for example.

That's exactly what I've always read. I suppose there are many things in this hobby that aren't recommended but there are always some people that seem to be successful with them.

vt_snowman- have you seen the awesome (and expensive) Helfrichi firefish?

 

[Squawkbert]

Me too - I think of them like I do dotty-backs (one per tank unless <3's involved).

 

[vt_snowman87]

That's exactly what I've always read. I suppose there are many things in this hobby that aren't recommended but there are always some people that seem to be successful with them.

vt_snowman- have you seen the awesome (and expensive) Helfrichi firefish?

oh yes i seen the Helfrichi firefish from the internet, awesome.. but can't seem to spot any in my country.. so i guess purple firefish is my next best.. want to try having one each..

 

[Pallen81]

oh yes i seen the Helfrichi firefish from the internet, awesome.. but can't seem to spot any in my country.. so i guess purple firefish is my next best.. want to try having one each..

how large is your tank?

 

[Squawkbert]

Drs. F&S have Helfs in stock, but they aren't cheap ($169USD).

I guess compatability hinges on how discerning they are about "is that one of my own species?". They are all reputed to pick on their own kind unless they're paired.

If you have a good sized tank and a "plan b" if they don't get along, you might go for it...

 

[dorkfish]

how large is your tank?

ACoording to another thread of his/hers, 15 gal with a pair of maroon clowns and a copperband...

 

[SHK_ATK]

from saltwaterfish.com

The Firefish, a.k.a. Dartfish, is a magnificent little fish that's perfect for reef tanks. These fish have a white forebody and a "fiery" rearbody that is colored in a mix of red colors. The Firefish also has an elongated first dorsal spine that "jumps" up and down. These little fish have lots of personality and should be kept in a tank with lots of rockwork. The Firefish likes lots of crevices, caves, and overhangs where they can "hang" in place. These fish prefer to be kept in pairs and do well in the home aquarium. They are great for reef tanks and will accept most fish foods.These fish are also jumpers, so precautions should be taken to secure openings at the top of the aquarium.

The Dartfish family of fish are majestic little fish with an elongated body. They have long dorsal fins and small upturned mouths. This family of fish is usually found in pairs or small groups.