Mafia Game 2

this is all getting pretty confusing...but thats a good thing..

im sticking to my vote
 
*sniff* i smell a plan afoot.. but then again, if the mafia gets rid of me tonight, regardless of votes, which i'm sure my big mouth has caused, what's the loss of one mafia member like johnlarson gonna do? that would leave 3.. which can surely still decimate the town. i havent heard a word about the detective.. talk about a useless character this round. :rolleyes:

How could the 3 that are left "decimate" the town, Detective J double R? I still can't find where it says 4 mafia, was this private detective only knowledge.

I am not sure if you are the detecive or not, your death will tell us that. I am also unsure of who you claim to have investigated. Of the 16 people playing, you picked 2 right off the bat. So, the first night, you had a confirmed mafia member, but instead the next day voted to lynch an innoncent. You have been trying to lynch me, but did not investigate me?
 
you can try to poke holes in my work, but i'm the detective, and i think you are mafia. you are also the next on my list, so if i survive the night, i will know whether you are or not.


if i tried to pick off the mafia members right off before anyone knew anything but me, then i would be targeted by the mafia.. i had to get time to make sure everyone believed me.. seeing the level of suspicion by the townsfolk as well as who i know to be mafia and who i think to be mafia, it's hail-mary time.

Of course, you don't have to believe me, nobody does.. but when this is all over and i am long dead, you will see, i was right.
 
P.S We're up to thirteen for this game. Come on, let's get to sixteen. The mafia have some real powerhouse plays when there are four of them.

johnlarson, if you go back and read the signup thread, you would see that 16 players (which we attained) equals 4 mafia members. hence, my conclusion. :)

EDIT: and for easier referencing, it's post #15. ;)
 
Last edited:
I'm going to have to retract my position once more but only because I mis-read Coler's posts. I will not state exactly where but I will be reviewing it again. So sorry, Coler :)

I move back to I vote to LYNCH JOHNNYLARSON66
 
Also, anyone not voting to lynch J double R MUST be mafia. Why are you trying to take me out first?

meh I'm voting for you and I'm not mafia...I think JRR has had misread of the game and is shielding the real detective.
 
LIES! Coler, you are mafia, this i know positively. your voting for johnlarson is merely a coverup.
 
IT IS NIGHT

The town has a restless day of name calling and finger-pointing. In the end, JOhnLarson66 gets the most votes with 6, followed by J double R with 4 and guppyguppyfish with 1.

The town as one turns to Johnlarson... who proudly displays his mafia tattoo before the town grinds him into ciclid flakes.

JohnLarson66 was Mafia

I need stuff from the mafia and detective at this time.

Night all.
 
so you still say you are the detective and you did uncover two mafia (me and daydaa) in two turns...nice work is all I can say.

edit : posted contemporaneously with Ogre
 
Last edited:
AquariaCentral.com