Mafia Game 3

[Dwarf Puffers]

Few, just got up, checked hotmail, responded to detective, and got the list of players and their rolls... Very good list, KotD, kudos to you .

Here are the votes:

Jdub - Cory Lover, Neon Julie

Neon Julie - Jdub, Fish Lady, Coler, Jessica

John Larson - Ogre

Fish Lady - IceH20

Night will begin in 24 hours. KotD is starting to feel ill. All we can do is hope he's okay.

 

[captaincaveman9]

SInce I don't know when I'll be on next I'm Voting for NeonJulie I just get a serious mafia vibe from her

 

[OgreMkV]

Dwarf, you didn't get my vote

 

[Madcrawdad]

I have a few suspicions about who is mafia, I still thin Mac is trying to steer the populas, and I dont think its for the good of the town.

here's the thing that scares me....as was mentioned earlier, I think I've given what I would assume to be pretty obvious advice in playing this game, and also presented some pretty logical arguments. so when folks just say...'his words don't ring true,' or 'he's not acting in the good of the town', all I can ask is that people give examples, please. read through posts and you'll see no evidence of me misleading anyone...no evidence of me waffling on anything. seriously folks, give evidence so other folks can decide....just saying 'I have no evidence, but the guy is a liar' is a crazy hunch, and it's way too early in the game to start playing crazy hunches.

Its the people that seem to know a lot that scare me.

talk about trying to lead, and not for the good of the town....isn't that just another way of saying 'Hey let's just start tossing the guys who are posting their logic and really thinking hard about this game'? not a real sound strategy for the townies IMO....what are you really afraid of cavie?

 

[Dwarf Puffers]

Votes:

6 NeonJulie: CC, Ogre, Jdub, Fish Lady, Coler, Jessica

2 Jdub - Cory Lover, Neon Julie

John Larson - Ogre

Fish Lady - IceH20

Players yet to vote:

Plantling
bkw1982
MadCrawdad
Jdub
DD
Mee-mee
Sovran
"13"
John Larson
Jensons

Wow, 10 people left to vote... I may have to extend the day an hour tommorow just to give them a chance to vote...

Night will begin in 20 hours, give or take, probably on the give side if I manage to sleep in (7:00 is considered that) and there's still lots of people who haven't voted.

 

[NeonJulie]

I really wish I was mafia at this point, this would be much more enjoyable. Well as I said this game isn't one bit about truth or playing outright and openly. It's about popularity and how to seduce others into voting along with you. I definitely don't intend to sit here all day today and listen to twenty people give weak reasons why my extroverted attempts at this game must make me mafia, I have said absolutely everything possible there is to be said. If you guys are truly innocent, you'll go back and read. Starting with post one. It's all there if you're innocently looking for it.

I will say that anyone who keeps pointing to some type of alliance with IceH20 is off their rocker. Or mafia. And the second is more likely. I never even once addressed one post to him. I don't know or care anything about him, except he was almost as unlucky as me for a completely useless reason. (Stepping up first.)

How they turn on you... Ogre you agreed with me on this reasoning. As did Madcrawdad. Now all you can say is "alliance with IceH20!" Well everybody, go back and look, they thought the same thing as me, that it was stupid to send Ice to the gallows for following instructions that people start the game rolling. I wasn't alone there.

I think the detective is around and operating, and people need to start listening. I believe the clues are there as well. But I can't change my vote (like it matters right?) because that just makes me look more evil?

Go back and read, innocents. Change votes, and see who's really a stickler for still trying to put me in danger. They've probably got it already figured out, and are trying to keep the town too busy to notice and too excitable about lynching me, you know, because of the evil-ness and stuff.

Notice how some people keep agreeing with me, "yeah part of that post is true" or "yeah we shouldn't waste our first day voting for a random reason" and then they add "but I still think we should vote for NJ." So... you don't believe it yourself, but still voting to lynch me?

*Puts up the CLOSED sign in the office, unplugs the phone, locks the door, and loads the water gun. And sits down to a tasty tabloid read. ACville's Paris Hampton sure is making headlines these days.*

 

[plantling]

Call me crazy, but I halfway believe NeonJ. I'm holding off my vote 'cause there are still a lot of lurkers yet to be heard from. Townies need to speak their minds and to do so rashly to minimize confusion, so other townies and the good 4 will be able to distinguish who's who.

 

[Madcrawdad]

How they turn on you... Ogre you agreed with me on this reasoning. As did Madcrawdad.

How did I turn on you? I know that I keep saying this, but from the get-go you voted to lynch me...to turn on you, I would have had to have been with you....NEVER HAPPENED.

Notice how some people keep agreeing with me, "yeah part of that post is true" or "yeah we shouldn't waste our first day voting for a random reason" and then they add "but I still think we should vote for NJ." So... you don't believe it yourself, but still voting to lynch me?

the 'yeah we shouldn't waste time voting for a random reason,' would be me....but I never said for anyone to vote for you. I'm just pointing out some oddities in your game thus far, I sincerely doubt that I'll be voting for you tonight.

before some of your more recent posts I was 50/50 with you in terms of being mafia. the fact that you've hinted that you may be the detective (especially so early in day2) seems desperate. I'm not saying that you absolutely aren't the detective, but if you are, you've pretty much trashed the role. the mafia will be gunning for you, and the only way for you to live is if the doctor protects you every night (keeping him from protecting anyone else for the remainder of the game). So the problem I see here is that if you're detective, the role may have been rendered powerless by your veiled revelation....on the other hand, if people choose to let you off the hook because they think you're the detective and you end up NOT being the detective then you can run roughshod thru the game deceiving at every chance. in the meantime, the good doctor would be tied up protecting you every night while mafia pick off townies at will...make sense?

 

[NeonJulie]

er hmm... I never hinted I'm the detective. What I said was I now believe that the detective is out there, telling us which way to go. But it's not me.

Edit: Still turned on me. Because at first you said you didn't think I'm mafia. Now every post is "she must be mafia."

Anyway - have you SEEN the votes? Does it matter? Do you honestly believe I have any chance of outliving today? At this point not even the doctor can save me, if I'm lynched. What I need right now, is a darn priest. *lol*

 

[Coler]

As I said :

My vote is with NeonJulie but now I'm deciding between Ogre and NJ...what do you say about Ogre NJ ?

There's a ways to go in the day...I would be interested in hearing neonjulie's thoughts on who we should vote for (not necessarily as against Ogre who has only one vote), as opposed to a simple plea not to be lynched, which is what anyone would say in that position.