i dont see a way we can turn i t off, i tried goin invis but that didnt help, could a mod disable that feature.....im sure no one uses it anyway. you dont even hav to pm just open it up and it state it.....
Mafia Game #4 The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
I disagree.....If it was done, I wouldn't call it cheating, but I don't know if I'd want to continue the game. It's definitely an unfair advantage in my book, and whether you're mafia or townie, the field needs to be as level as possible. This new development has the potential to compromise every future mafia game on AC in my opinion.
Just my thougts...take them or leave them.
Here's how things stand currently.
Mee-Mee: 13 Votes --- Hooked Newbie, judgemax, plantling, Madcrawdad, johnlarson66, SHK_ATK, Sovran, FishLady22, Charlie_ Stubbs, ZSandmann, OgreMvK, Dangerdoll, coler, (In posted order)
It is interesting there are no other nominees. Means either A) Mafia have this one up as a loss and cut Mee-Mee loose. B) Mafia have not voted yet, or will switch later when someone else is nominated. C) All the Mafia have not voted yet. (Extremely unlikely) D) Mee-Mee is innocent (I don't think so)
Mee-Mee: 13 Votes --- Hooked Newbie, judgemax, plantling, Madcrawdad, johnlarson66, SHK_ATK, Sovran, FishLady22, Charlie_ Stubbs, ZSandmann, OgreMvK, Dangerdoll, coler, (In posted order)
It is interesting there are no other nominees. Means either A) Mafia have this one up as a loss and cut Mee-Mee loose. B) Mafia have not voted yet, or will switch later when someone else is nominated. C) All the Mafia have not voted yet. (Extremely unlikely) D) Mee-Mee is innocent (I don't think so)
I am changing my vote from Mee-mee to Coler
my guess is that someone may have been watching his profile, and when night ended saw that he was the one PMing (maybe sending a hit to rbishop).
Coler IS the Don......
Set 'em up, guys....let's knock 'em down. Won't this be fun!!??
my guess is that someone may have been watching his profile, and when night ended saw that he was the one PMing (maybe sending a hit to rbishop).
Coler IS the Don......
Set 'em up, guys....let's knock 'em down. Won't this be fun!!??
Gosh I'm posting like a mad person today. By my notes GuppyGuppyFish will die an embarrassing and cruel death tonight. this will be night three and she left mid way threw Day 1. Just wanted to stick that out there.
well i guess the game will go on the pmers will just have to pm bishop another way, email, yahoo, smoke signals, telepathy, moris code, etc, etc
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
/game off :mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2::mad2:
Cut it out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1) It's a fracking game. The first time I reffed this thing, I said I would pull the plug if it got out of hand. As far as I'm concerned, rbishop should pull the plug now and drop the whole thing never to be brought up again.
2) Cheating - is wrong. There was a specter of it last game. And I'm sick of people who want to win at any costs. This is a GAME... it has RULES. If you choose to ignore those rules to gain an unfair advantage, then you can take a flying leap off the nearest tall building.
3) You guys have wasted 4 PAGES of posts on something that was dealt with 10-20 pages ago. It's over, let it go.
OK, Rant over... to continue in a gentler tone.
4) ZSandmann... the mafia should have their own private forum on another server to discuss mafia actions. That's how I set up my games and I gave that info to rb and KOTD for last game.
5) JMax, <remove snippy comment, because I'm trying to be nice> When you pull a list of all 6 mafia members and the towns roles and declare them to be accurate... you have to understand that we don't believe you.
To quote Carl Sagan, "Extraordinary events require extraordinary explanation". If you had come out and said, I think Mee-mee is mafia. Then we probably would have believed you. I think mee-mee is mafia. The next day you could say KOTD is mafia. Not totally sure about that one, but THE REST OF US would have had another days worth of information to process and consider.
If you can't understand why everyone in this game can't see your point of view, then you should explain it to us. I know we've asked several times.
Take a look at my post this morning. I copied EVERY post made by Hooked Newbie. I have examined it very carefully. I'm not a trained CJ analyst, but I am a trained scientist and I've been doing stuff like this for well over 20 years.
When I say, I don't believe you. I'm not being mean. There's not enough evidence for it. If you have a unique way of putting that evidence together, then I'd like to hear it. Why do you have to let rbishop decide to post the information or not? Unless it involves information outside this thread.
For the purposes of the game, the only information we have is what is in this thread. PM, viewing status, location, number of Tetras in tank, do not apply and should not be used for the game. Anything other than info from this thread, I do consider cheating.
Now, can we play the game without anyone's feelings getting hurt or should we shut it down?
Finally, I have reviewed this post and edited it several times to decrease the anger that I feel right now. If I have offended anyone with this final draft, then cope. I can't make it any better.
/game on
Now, I'd like to bring up something for everyone else to consider. I believe that JMax's list is not 100% accurate. I think most of us feel that way.
We should consider what we will do if JMax's list is 100% inaccurate. It is very difficult for me to say that JMax is mafia. In fact, based on the doctor's actions, I believe it impossible. However, proof of innocence does not imply accuracy of predictions.
I still believe that mee-mee is mafia. Others that I blieve may be mafia are SHK-ATK, bkw1982, charlie stubbs (low probability), KOTD, and John Larson (who will get a good examination of thread postings shortly).
Those I believe to be innocent are ZSandmann, Madcrawdad (even though I want him to be mafia), and Fishlady22... for no real reason other than a feeling (doesn't matter much as she's not terribly involved.
Again, mee-mee being mafia, does not imply the rest of the list is accurate. I encourage the town to continue your investigations and don't fall into complacency.
Cut it out!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
1) It's a fracking game. The first time I reffed this thing, I said I would pull the plug if it got out of hand. As far as I'm concerned, rbishop should pull the plug now and drop the whole thing never to be brought up again.
2) Cheating - is wrong. There was a specter of it last game. And I'm sick of people who want to win at any costs. This is a GAME... it has RULES. If you choose to ignore those rules to gain an unfair advantage, then you can take a flying leap off the nearest tall building.
3) You guys have wasted 4 PAGES of posts on something that was dealt with 10-20 pages ago. It's over, let it go.
OK, Rant over... to continue in a gentler tone.
4) ZSandmann... the mafia should have their own private forum on another server to discuss mafia actions. That's how I set up my games and I gave that info to rb and KOTD for last game.
5) JMax, <remove snippy comment, because I'm trying to be nice> When you pull a list of all 6 mafia members and the towns roles and declare them to be accurate... you have to understand that we don't believe you.
To quote Carl Sagan, "Extraordinary events require extraordinary explanation". If you had come out and said, I think Mee-mee is mafia. Then we probably would have believed you. I think mee-mee is mafia. The next day you could say KOTD is mafia. Not totally sure about that one, but THE REST OF US would have had another days worth of information to process and consider.
If you can't understand why everyone in this game can't see your point of view, then you should explain it to us. I know we've asked several times.
Take a look at my post this morning. I copied EVERY post made by Hooked Newbie. I have examined it very carefully. I'm not a trained CJ analyst, but I am a trained scientist and I've been doing stuff like this for well over 20 years.
When I say, I don't believe you. I'm not being mean. There's not enough evidence for it. If you have a unique way of putting that evidence together, then I'd like to hear it. Why do you have to let rbishop decide to post the information or not? Unless it involves information outside this thread.
For the purposes of the game, the only information we have is what is in this thread. PM, viewing status, location, number of Tetras in tank, do not apply and should not be used for the game. Anything other than info from this thread, I do consider cheating.
Now, can we play the game without anyone's feelings getting hurt or should we shut it down?
Finally, I have reviewed this post and edited it several times to decrease the anger that I feel right now. If I have offended anyone with this final draft, then cope. I can't make it any better.
/game on
Now, I'd like to bring up something for everyone else to consider. I believe that JMax's list is not 100% accurate. I think most of us feel that way.
We should consider what we will do if JMax's list is 100% inaccurate. It is very difficult for me to say that JMax is mafia. In fact, based on the doctor's actions, I believe it impossible. However, proof of innocence does not imply accuracy of predictions.
I still believe that mee-mee is mafia. Others that I blieve may be mafia are SHK-ATK, bkw1982, charlie stubbs (low probability), KOTD, and John Larson (who will get a good examination of thread postings shortly).
Those I believe to be innocent are ZSandmann, Madcrawdad (even though I want him to be mafia), and Fishlady22... for no real reason other than a feeling (doesn't matter much as she's not terribly involved.
Again, mee-mee being mafia, does not imply the rest of the list is accurate. I encourage the town to continue your investigations and don't fall into complacency.
OgreMkV
Father of Earth's Next Emperor
erv: erv: erv: Thx ogre for the number two quote in the top ten AC quotes
anyway.....back to the game at hand....again
wait last question. whats the point of doing game off and game on lol
