Mafia Game #4 The Play

[johnlarson66]

I vote to Lynch Coler

As stated, I will follow judgemax's lead.

I am pretty sure if Coler is found innocent, this move will cause me to get lynched. Which I will understand. Blindly following judgemax would be a good mafia move. I just ask, before going after me, know for sure Coler was innocent.

I also am over trying to find holes in judgemax's game play. She thinks she is on to something and has offered to put her on neck on the line for it. There has to be some weight to that.

This has been done in the past by people without investigative powers and they were right.

The only way I see to put this to rest is to lynch one of judgemax's suspects. I do not have any better suggestions.

 

[judgemax]

Yes indeed. In fact, I begin to find your screenname a little hypocritical. *lol*

That is my screen name, because, My dogs names are

judge, the old male,

jury, the younger more fit female, and

J.C, because she is the first pup, in the line of our(juvinial court)

some of the other pups from that litter being named, gavel, D.A. mason, verdict, convict, baliff, and justice, just to name a few..

max, is the cats name, after the dog, in how the grinch stole christmas...

 

[NeonJulie]

I am not the mayor, I am just an ordinary plane jane citizen, I am just a smart one, see at the end of the game if I am right, then , well, you will know, I doubt at this point the mafia will hit me, unless they directly want to give them selves away, ..If you want to lynch coreylover go ahead, but I would strongly consider watching the 4 names I gave you...

Page 53!! I progress.

We are to trust you the ENTIRE game, blow the game if that's what you were asking us to do, because all that matters is that after the game is OVER... we get to hear how right you are! It's almost like sitting for a cookie. If we're good, if we sit and speak...

I guess I am not smart.


Well here you beg the mafia to kill you, to confirm your plans. AND THEY DO! Now normally that is bad bad news for the mafia, because it makes your list look good. Unless as it was already said, the whole thing is a setup to begin with. Most people... do not beg to be killed. Oh I think I've gone down this line of reasoning before, and I'm pretty sure you ignored the questions the first time. Maybe I'll repeat them.

Again, don't go for Corey Lover? Man are you guys in cahoots or what at this point? Again, what is it about him that you need to keep him around? Other than the fact that it looks like he may be spilling potentially useful names from his "big mouth" he said something about? Is that it? You're simply just going off of his list, because he listed them before he went down? Well, that is fairly simple - except that argument was not considered useful in Dangerdoll's case, in fact, it gets her off. But not in the case of Corey Lover.

But anyway, why do you keep protecting him, although later, it's known he's mafia? If you were able to figure out 4 of them, why couldn't you not figure HIM out? I think you, being smarter than us, knew he was, but I have to guess that he served a purpose for you, and in terms of explaining, this would have been a grand place, and a safe place, to start.

 

[NeonJulie]

and, Judge, I would strongly advise you post the basis for each name (I'd say that anyway even if you hadn't named me), especially as you are going on your own opinion and analysis.

Advised, advised, and yes, advised. Ignored...?

 

[judgemax]

now, so I do not get questioned again, I am leaving the computer, I have to go do a photo shoot for my daughter, So, i will be doing her hair and makeup, and then taking her pictures, I do not know how long it will take, and I need to do my dishes, so I assume, i won't be on till later.

 

[NeonJulie]

Hmmm, suspicious...My thought is that since CL is prolly going to get lynched anyways, the mafia might as well risk CL asking people who the mayor is. If we catch on to her, oh well 5 mafia left and possibly one dead mayor. Even if CL is innocent, why would the mayor reveal him/herself to the entire population. That's suicide in a post. If Cl truly is innocent then she should know that already. She will probably say that she was joking, but I'm not going to buy that.

Yes it is... suicide. She SHOULD know that already, but I don't think she is joking, most people don't joke about retracting votes, and I'm not buying it either...

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Ok, I wanted to get this out early to see what everyone thinks and how some people respond. No fancy meter, just a few categories and a synopsis of my reasoning. If you disagree, please tell me why and give me your perspective. My mind is open.
Suspected Mafia:
Coler- I haven't played before so I'm not familiar enough with his style, but he really seems to scrambling to throw out a name for people to latch onto and look away from him. To me his posts today have pretty well confirmed the suspicions that so many have. (Unless I see something very strange, I Vote to Lynch Coler.


Leaning Mafia:
KOTD- Seems defensive and hasn't really offered up alot of helpful posts.
Charlie_stubbs- Seems very quick to "Go with the flow" for whomever is the current popular choice. This could be being new to the game (which I can relate to), but he's offered nothing but cheerleading and wagon jumping from what everything I've read.

Completely Unknown (and therefor a bit scary)
Jensons- Not much info at all on her, but she's close to "Leaning innocent" for me.

JPappy- Shades of Charlie, but not enough posts for me to place him "Leaning mafia".

Plantling- Again, close to "Leaning innocent", but I honestly don't have much of a read.

Leaning Innocent
Ogre- Lots of helpful posts and I like the idea of everyone posting their reasoning.

Fishlady- Close to "Unknown" for me, not much to go on, but what there was seems to have been trying to help the town.

Neon Julie- Seems to be trying to help the town, though I admit that I was tempted to place you in Mafia status just for the amount of reading you made me do today.

bkw1982- Started out with alot of good posts and quieted down as soon as a couple people either named him or questioned some of his info.

Believed to be Innocent
Madcrawdad- Lots of good posts and seems very focused on playing well and helping the town. I wouldn't expect to see that combination if he weren't innocent.

Max- Regardless of the list and drama that ensued, to me the Dr. saving her pretty well cements it for me.

DangerDoll- Hasn't posted much, but her points have struck chords for me and I believe helped the town.

Zsand- Same as Mad from what I've seen. Very active and helpful.
Max- Regardless of the list and drama that ensued, to me the Dr. saving her pretty well cements it for me.

 

[NeonJulie]

I don't know if corey lover is mafia, if he is well great, we will then know 5, I am not saying save him, I am saying, that i KNOW 4 OF THEM, if I am right, ..and if coreylover is mafia, that leaves one ...and acville will be safe again! ..

I am not the mayor, or any special role, I am however smart enough to use the information, that we all have access to, and I guess, you guys can either trust me, or lynch me, but when you lynch me, and It says innocent after my name, look closely at my 4 picks...lynch one, if they are mafia, then you'll try the next, if they aren't well, then i will forever be an angel , with no halo...

Uh oh wait... the confused, 'I might be wrong' and 'I just don't know about CL' is back. Wait, now the TOTAL COMPLETE CAPITAL LETTER CONFIDENCE. Indeed if this is criminology 101, it must be very confusing for attorneys and criminals to ever get a fix on you, the way you constantly fluctuate.

Again, you claim to know the whole game by now, as a normal person with NO special role, but you're smart enough. Smart enough to use the information that we all have access to. *hangs head*

Wait, now you're asking to be killed by the town? And what the heck does all this forever angel no halo business mean... this is as bizzarre a comment as I've seen. One would say... maybe it had a double meaning. Should halos mean anything to us? Angels? Forever? And what's with the death wish, are you bored of the game?

One would say you enjoy playing the part of the victim already before the fact... if not by the mafia whacking you appear to be hoping for, then by the town...?

 

[NeonJulie]

I also wanted to bring to everyones attention Neon Julie defending Cory Lover. So once Cory Lover is lynched tonight and ends up mafia, i believe we all should take a closer look at her. and here is the link to her post. http://www.aquariacentral.com/forums/showpost.php?p=975417&postcount=489

i have my suspicions about mee mee as well...but im not going to make any rash assumptions due to the fact that i mostly skimmed today. I will go back and read more tonight to see if i can find some good reading material for you all

Yes, let's all look at me, because once, in the first hour, of the first day, I said 'maybe we shouldn't hang somebody on their first post, that MIGHT be a bit presumptuous.' (Although inside I was screaming 'mafia mafia mafia' and had I been there this present night, he would have landed my vote like this book I'm writing landing on someone's desk. *lol*)

But uh, let's not look at Judgemax... who has not only defended Corey Lover... she's begged us not to vote for him... she's not sure about him... she wants us to vote for someone else, oh anybody, take your pick, of any of 5, 6, 10, how many people is it up to now?

If you want to look at me, for taking a fair take on everybody and giving them the benefit of the doubt, then perhaps you too, should closely look at Judgemax and whatever game she has been playing.

 

[ZSandmann]

HN: I like the list, agrees a good deal with my notes. Some of our middle are spun around such as BKW but for right now that works fine. Because there are enough suspects right now to separate the apples from the oranges. No need currently to worry with separating the navel oranges from the blood oranges from the comquats, etc.