Mafia Game #4 The Play

So, my new list is this, and I will give reasons..lmao..

bkw..your a good player, and I read you so wrong, I am nervous to not have you up on my list at this point...

JL22: I dunno man, you did follow along with me, and you were the only one who supported me, but as you pointed out yourself, it would be smart to align yourself with me if you are mafia?..was that a hint?..

Hooked newbie: you are still there, I just can't let that go, lmao..sorry:) and since coler, and several other mafia members threw him under the wheel so to speak, maybe they were using reverse psychology on us, ..hoping, that would make him look more innocent, cause, why would they throw the last one, under the wheel...

these are in no order, and I still have my eye on ogre?..I dunno, hes good, ..but is he really that good?...

none of my reasonings are strong, And, i am going from memory, which is about full, so ..lets discuss..
 
Jensons said:
Hi all! I just got home from subbing summer school. GREAT JOB TO ALL THE TOWNIES LAST NIGHT!!!! Only 1 mafia lest! WooHoo!!!!! I would like to say, and I think if you look at my posts from last night you will see that I am not lying, just before we were all "put to sleep" by rbishop, that I did a heck of a job choosing KOTD. I was the vigilante. I pulled up all of KOTD's posts, and made the best decision I could. I have to say, in the name of honesty, that I was propelled by Ogre's suspicions. I am positive that he is innocent in this game. If you doubt my inocence still, look at Coler's posts from yesterday. I believe that he found me out, and was trying to garner votes for me before his demise. I will post my suspicions later, but I wanted to get this out there asap. Good job townies! ~brandy
Click to expand...
I knew I knew I knew I knew! there was something about you!!!! You did an amazing job, congrats! Good thing too, you were my number one Mafia candidate, thanks for coming out so to speak. Not good for bkw, Candidate number 2.
 
Judge your list is carbon to mine except Ogre. I don't think he is the lone ranger. What I do think is that one of the three "Most likely" may indeed be... I don't want to put it out there but if you read between the lines there it is.
 
I think the Mafia man is either

johnlarson66 or bkw1982: I know they will say this is because they voted for me on Night 1 but that isn't the case at all. To be honest its more because I can see reasons why everyone else is NOT Mafia so by process of elimination they must be. Both have played a smart game, but I do wonder about bkw the most of the two. As Ogre points out bkw has not been voting thus keeping himself from having to defend those votes. However, he is active in the thread, why not vote? bkw I would like to hear your answer to this. jl66 you have done some work but really haven't put forward much for the Town to work with. You have what would be called a "flat character" in literature, I have a much greater view of bkw's game play. That scares me. Again I'm not sighting a billion posts here these are just observations. I've dug out posts on both in the past so I hope folks will go back and look at those.
 
I vote to lynch bkw1982

I'm tired, I've had a rough day, I'm POed, I'm grumpy, and I burned the Fracking brownies. It's not Bkw's fault, but I'm taking it out on him. Sorry. I do think you're the mafia.
 
I am at my mother-inlaws in North Carolina. I am glad I was able to vote before I boarded the plane this morning. I am not going to have much computer time, plus she is on dail-up.

I stand behind my vote for Hooked Newbie. The ONLY reason for this is that HN is on judgemax's list. I have stated that I would follow it until it was wrong.

So far it has been right.

Unless the mayor comes out and says "soandso is the last mafia" then I see no reason not to vote for HN.

If I am thought as mafia, no problem. If HN is found to be innocent and I make the next best suspect, then lynch me. At this point in the game the town can spare a few. The mafia have not played as a team at all and if I am a member of this mafia, then I DESERVE to die.

I think the lone mafia member should concede and we go to the next game. This game could last for another two weeks trying to find the last one.

Once again, I see no reason not to follow judgemax's lead on this. There is nothing wrong with following. It is what got us to where we are as a town.

I say let's follow the list and see what happens the next day. That is what I suggested yesterday, and it turned out good. If someone could give a good reason not to trust judgemax's list, then I am all for it. The way I see it. Only the mayor could have a better choice.
 
ZSandmann said:
I think the Mafia man is either

johnlarson66 or bkw1982: I know they will say this is because they voted for me on Night 1 but that isn't the case at all. To be honest its more because I can see reasons why everyone else is NOT Mafia so by process of elimination they must be. Both have played a smart game, but I do wonder about bkw the most of the two. As Ogre points out bkw has not been voting thus keeping himself from having to defend those votes. However, he is active in the thread, why not vote? bkw I would like to hear your answer to this. jl66 you have done some work but really haven't put forward much for the Town to work with. You have what would be called a "flat character" in literature, I have a much greater view of bkw's game play. That scares me. Again I'm not sighting a billion posts here these are just observations. I've dug out posts on both in the past so I hope folks will go back and look at those.
Click to expand...

Z, here's my thoughts on jl66 & bkw...

JL66:
First thing I noticed is that he mentioned that CoryLover was 'renegade' mafia. I never got that impression, and we saw that NeonJulie and Mee-mee both tried to come to his aid when cornered. Cory Lover did confirm post-mortem that his inbox was full, and that he hadn't been receiving PMs from his team-mates.

Second thing is that I was a little surprised when JL66 lined up behind JudgeMax as quickly as he did, but the more I thought about it, it did make sense to test her list. If JL66 were mafia, I'm not so sure that he'd be as willing to take down Coler or King. Thing that bothers me here, though, is I don't remember him making a case for taking down either of them....only that 'I plan to vote however JudgeMax does.' Seems a little out of character.

BKW
Z, you made a case, and later I pointed a couple of things out I found unusual about BKW's behavior. Actually it was me (not Ogre) who pointed out that BKW hadn't voted on days 2 & 3 (although I'm surprised Ogre never mentioned it if he was analyzing voting patterns as mentioned earlier in the thread). When you don't vote, you don't really stick your neck out. Also one thing of note, is that BKW and King both used a similar argument when confronted with being mafia...something like 'oh, just because I don't copy and paste and make long posts, that makes me mafia?' I'm pretty sure that BKW used this argument before King, though, so it may not be a valid point.
 
As far as my "character" I was mafia game 2 and the mayor game 3.

I have followed because I thought it was best for the town.
 
I've had suspicions about your top 3 at one time or another, also, Judge. BKW's voting record, his mafia picks, lurking at times, etc. But since you had said you thought he was innocent, I just let it go. And JL was too eager to follow you. And he was also one of the last to cast their vote for Nola. Yes, I'm like a dog with a bone about that night, but it seems all the other voting nights have been such landslides, there's not much info to garner from them. And I've had mixed feelings about HN. He seems like a nice enough fellow, but some of his posts on the first day has me wondering.

I'd like to hear more from these guys but I'm inclined to vote for BKW because he whacked Ogre with a wet fish in Mafia3. J/K. Really it's the voting. How could you not vote, especially if you had time to post?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.
AquariaCentral.com
Top Bottom