MAFIA #5 The Play.....

[clown-lover]

its still a bit early for me to be suspicious about anyone..i think colers first post was just to clarify things because of what happened last game..but who knows..

I would have to agree with that statement to a certain extent. He definitely is a different animal in this game so far..

 

[mee-mee]

I will be checking back in later..Have to go to a babyshower....till then, be safe and sound Townies...

 

[Cory Lover]

CL enters the game after his embarrasing fall last time.

I'm a senior player....just like Mg is a senior guy:silly: And JM...your really smart....you were right last game lol....and I said you were telling the truth and I was right! See..I didn't lie lol!

Ok, game face on now.

Ok...I'm really suspicious of joander....just seeming a little whacko. I know he is a newbie but still.....

CL

 

[Hooked Newbie]

To be fair Coler is more like he was in Round 3 than Round 4 right now.

The new players have me at a loss, I have nothing to compare to, should make this round interesting.

Watch the Newbies! BTW- I picked up some frosting for you for that mousepad.

 

[judgemax]

yea.. but we have to get the ball rolling some how..

Which also brings up a great point Judge.. You were innocent last game, you'd make a great DON...

That does sound possible...she did play a great Innocent...whose to say she is or isn't the Don..... :lipssealedsmilie:

LMAO..I would make a great don, lol, however, its not going to happen in this game.not sure if i could pull it off, lmao, i almost got myself killed as an innocent, couldn't imagine having to be mafia..

 

[KingOfTheDeep]

CL enters the game after his embarrasing fall last time.

I'm a senior player....just like Mg is a senior guy:silly: And JM...your really smart....you were right last game lol....and I said you were telling the truth and I was right! See..I didn't lie lol!

Ok, game face on now.

Ok...I'm really suspicious of joander....just seeming a little whacko. I know he is a newbie but still.....

CL

being wacko is not a sign of being mafia..its a sign of being a red sox fan..LOL

but yeah..i just re-read the whole thread so far and it seems like he's being a bit erratic with his posts...he's either a REALLY confused innocent..or mafia..im not quite sure which one i want to believe yet..

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Or is he possibly thinking the same thing as me, that he wants US to think that he wouldnt be calling attention to himself if he was a mafia, so he does just that, even though he IS a mafia.

This seems a very odd statement. I'm not going to vote on it yet, but VERY suspicious!

 

[IceH2O]

I don't know.. DD seems to have come out of the gate right away pointing her finger at others when there has been very little substantive posting happening.

Also if you combine the fact that she was an innocent last game she would be a great contender to be mafia this game.

Then we have the following people who haven't even posted yet..

bkw - was always on the suspicions list of a couple
corey lover - was mafia hit right away
jensons - really didn't post a lot..
jpappy - ?? hard to read

Last game there were a couple of mafia posting right away and when you look at the above list it would make sense that at least one of these four would be mafia. Just for the fact that they are probably reading, trying to come up with a game plan and chatting off site.

Nice observation but the roles are determined by a generator that Rb uses to pick our places in the game. He wouldn't say well he/she was innocent last game so I'll make them mafia this game. There are 22 of us and last game was like 25 of us. It wouldn't be possible to say one deserves the role over the other.

I've thought about this as well when playing (as now) as an innocent...thing is though we have to get information on day one, and votes = reactions = information...having said that, as the day goes on, there is nothing wrong with voting no one at the end of it (I know everyone says 'that only helps the mafia' but think about it; how does it help the town if you don't have a least a probably suspect in your mind to vote for, and you end up lynching a fellow innocent.)

It is very likely that a lynching on day one will be an innocent. If it's me, all I ask is that you all learn from the experience

Classic mafia play : day one, rely on the statistics, hide your votes around the place as long as the town have picked an innocent, day two blame one or two of the innocents for the lynching and try and get them killed. Its then only on day three that the mafia have to actually try, if that all works out for them and they would hope to be 4 townies down by then.

I tend to find that mafia, especially new mafia players, cannot resist a lynchwagon early on day one though.

Now, having said all that, my mafia meter is perked by 4 people since my first post, and we'll all continue on learning as we go during the course of the day.

We might end up with a great suspect for a lynching yet.

My thoughts exactly Coler. Except....throwing out an obvious plan like that will make the mafia change their plan or is the mafia throwing that plan out there to make us think they are changing their plan and will run with the plan stated? hmmm

now why would i be TRYING to act like a mafia? As i have said before, i just do not know how the game is played. It seems odd to me that coler would just come out and say that "Im and Innocent dont vote for me".... its just not what you do... but then again, when you think, why would he come out and say that if he WAS indeed a mafia, wouldnt you think he would know that he was calling attention to himself by saying that, and wouldnt he not want to call attention to himself?

Or is he possibly thinking the same thing as me, that he wants US to think that he wouldnt be calling attention to himself if he was a mafia, so he does just that, even though he IS a mafia.

I have to agree with JM that this post looks like a classic newbie Mafia slipup. Anyone remember CL?

 

[judgemax]

This seems a very odd statement. I'm not going to vote on it yet, but VERY suspicious!

I think it was a slip, i think he told on himself, if not, hes as bad at being innocent, as cl was being mafia!, lmao

 

[clown-lover]

LMAO..I would make a great don, lol, however, its not going to happen in this game.not sure if i could pull it off, lmao, i almost got myself killed as an innocent, couldn't imagine having to be mafia..

So come clean.. In that last game.. PM stood for Protect Me right?