Search results

The rules state as follows: "Each night you need to PM me who you desire to have hit." - The Don-Specific Rules "If the Don is killed you may continue to send names for the hit each night." - Evil Specific Rules So it could be taken as the Don needs to post the hit UNTIL he/she dies or that...

I am confused. What game thread are YOU reading? What does DD being a UD risk have to do with Kashta being a lynch candidate? And when did I say anything about 4 votes?

If any scum teammate can send in the hit than I'll be withdrawing my vote on Pappy. If it needs to be the Don until his/her death than it stays on Pappy. I too would like clarification now on that, because of the below:

Just to clarify, I am doing all of my theories based on the Don being the only person who can place a hit or change it.

If the hit was locked on Kashta than the following people are possible Dons: Myself - having not been around there for the nightfall, I am obviously a prime suspect for being a Mafia Don. Besides this, I suppose you can say Kashta was questioning me on Day 1 but by that logic the hit would...

Ah. You are correct in regards to User, but he isn't really involved in this except that he was an extra option. Remove any reference of User, because the argument I have isn't based on User, it's based on wanting to ensure that DD was lynched so that the hit would definitely go through on Kashta.

Pappy, my theory is a bit of a stretch I admit, and yes it makes assumptions - but so far the only other theory for why the hit was on Kashta that I've seen is that the scum team is incompetent, which is (as I've stated before) the most illogical possible theory to make in a game without any...

Ok, prior to responding to some other posts I figure I may as well post my loose suspect list: Pappy - For reasons stated already. User - If he put the hit on Kashta when it looked like DD was going to be voted and then left like he claims he did, it would explain why Pappy voted DD to ensure...

But why not vote DD? At the time, DD had 3 votes and Kashta had 2 - if DD came back and voted Kashta it would have put the hit at risk. By voting DD and bringing it up to 4 votes on DD with 2 on Kashta, Pappy would have ensured that DD was the lynch and Kashta the hit while making himself look...

Well, in regards to the angels - they will do fine in a 55gal tank. I do not know if they will get along with the Severums, but since they are both cichlids I'd be careful. The silver dollars are high-end plant eaters, meaning they will demolish anything green and not plastic in your tank. If...

What other, less risky options are there? What assumptions do I keep making? Why do both you and wiz keep mentioning my assumptions in a game based on 'assuming' that everyone is your enemy and 'assuming' that people you vote for are scum based on what you've come to know? As for you being Don...

Is his kicking of bushes the only factor that makes my logic flawed, or do you see more? Because I for one think that Pappy could definitely pull off looking very helpful to the town while actually turning everyone against each other.

Well, the logic seems fairly straightforward. The following things are fact: 1) Until nightfall, DD could have come back and placed a vote on either Kashta OR User in order to create a tie. 2) Until nightfall, Pappy could have voted Kashta OR User and created a tie. 3) The mafia team chose to...

Am I correct with these being the final votes taken at nightfall? (4) DD by FF1, user, Kashta, Pappy - Innocent, UD/Lynch (2) Kashta by 2Hobbs, Bally - Innocent, Mafia Hit (2) Un by wiz, Zaffy Note: Bold are votes after the last vote update by Bish day 1. Assuming that the scum team is...

What I found to be 'muddying the waters' wasn't his questions (those are good) but the fact that he gives no indication as to his own opinion on the matter. This assuming that he didn't do so and I just missed it while reading.

Ok, sure. If so than I would say (off the top of my head) that Pappy is scum, but that is off of a gut feeling I have regarding his gameplay so far. If they weren't here at nightfall than it would have had to be me, as Bally and UN were both around to see Kashta getting votes but I was long...

Can I just have that 130... :perv: Awesome find with the giant tanks :D

I'm going to be frank, after a reread of day 1... I have no solid leads whatsoever. I do have to agree a bit with Wiz's comment (100) regarding UN and his vote, how he voted on someone who was in the lead while saying scum liked the way the game was going. My gut says that Pappy is hiding...

Sorry for the crappy day 1 gameplay everyone, I'll try to do better day 2. Sucky nightfall, both of the people I suspected for reasons unrelated to continual focus on myself were innocent and are dead :tombstone: It's late, I'm pooped-ish (no thinking allowed) so I'll read the posts after I...

Since Wizard Asked My Player Opinions: wizard - Has been putting in a lot of effort to 'root out scum', though much of it is directed at questioning my logic and then questioning my answers. Kashta - Appears to only be making small comments while trying to look helpful. A little wish-washy...