Am I crazy for not changing water?

Your absolutly right, you beat me to saying it. If you have a fish tank, you should take care of it to the fullest extent. You should not neglect doing water changes or checking water parameters. Fish keeping is a great hobby, but whats the point of having fish if your not going to take care of them. :mad:
 
Last edited:
I think you're a good example of not-overcrowding your tank (which is something of a problem for me). One of the biggest problems we see in the hobby is people who put dozens of fish in 10 and 20g tanks, and you've got a large one with with enough filtration, and you've been prudent in stocking your tank. Good for you. Now, having said that, I think it would be equally prudent for you to start water changes, a minimum of 10 gallons every two weeks.

Oh, and welcome to Aquaria Central, home of the most diligent water changers on the internet. :)

Regards,

Val
 
Originally posted by NJ Devils Fan
Your absolutly right, you beat me to saying it. If you have a fish tank, you should take care of it to the fullest extent. You should not neglect doing water changes or checking water parameters. Fish keeping is a great hobby, but whats the point of having fish if your not going to take care of them. :mad:

Whoa, easy there! I try to take care of my fish, but I am a newbie, that's why I posted in this forum. I only asked because I know people who don't do water changes often and people who do, and it's just conflicting.

I actually have a Python already, and I cleaned the gravel last night. I guess I should have been more specific, I do clean the gravel probably every 2 months, maybe even that's too long? When I do that I take half the water out. Also I have fake plants.

I check the water regulary, the PH is around 8.2, Ammonia is always 0, Nitrite is 0. I having trouble figuring out the GH and KH, so I haven't been able to test that. Thanks for all the help, everybody.
 
Originally posted by val
I think you're a good example of not-overcrowding your tank (which is something of a problem for me). One of the biggest problems we see in the hobby is people who put dozens of fish in 10 and 20g tanks, and you've got a large one with with enough filtration, and you've been prudent in stocking your tank. Good for you. Now, having said that, I think it would be equally prudent for you to start water changes, a minimum of 10 gallons every two weeks.

Oh, and welcome to Aquaria Central, home of the most diligent water changers on the internet. :)

Regards,

Val

Thanks. I've actually been here for awhile, but my old user name didn't make it to the new board. I try not to over crowd, for some reason I like little fish who get along with each other. I've posted my specs on other boards and people have laughed at me saying I should just stock it with piranhas. I've had cichlids in it before, but I didn't like like their aggresive behavior. I then tried a goldfish and he just swam in circles, boring. So then I did some research first before buying these. It's fun to watch them interact with each other.
 
FYI if you do start doing water changes (and i think you should for all the aforementioned reasons), start off small, because even beneficial changes in water chemistry can shock fish if they happen to rapidly. fish are kind of wimpy that way.
 
you're probably right val,

We probably are the most diligent water changers on the net :D
 
Even in planted tanks, you want to do water changes. In growth accelerated plant tanks (co2 injection, high light, bi-daily nutrience addition), you want to do large water changes to remove any toxic substances from the water. Generally, if you notice mature leaves dying off quickly, that means your water is a bit toxic. All of my planted tanks get 40-50% water changes once a week.

As for fish only tanks, imho, regular water changes are important. Not only in removing nitrates, but other things that might have built up in your water. Nitrates are harmful in high concentrations, not only that, but they are also an indicator of other things that may be harmful in your tank that are undetectable by normal means. Put it this way, would you rather breath in polluted air, or fresh air? You can survive in both conditions, but you'd do much better in fresh air.

shmeeb001 brings up a good point. When you start doing your water changes, start very slowly. Begin with 5-10% once a week for a few weeks. Bring it up to 10-15% once a week after that for a few weeks, continue to do so until you are changing about 30-40% of the water once a week. Frequent water changes also helps stabilize your tank's chemistry. Many water changes makes your tank's chemistry similar to your tap water. So if for some reason you need to do an emergency large water change (ie. you drop a crap load of food by accident) you can do so w/o much shock to your fish. My fish only tanks get the same amount of water changed as my plant tanks... about 40-50%. I can say with confidence that if I do a very large water change (for example 80%), my fish will not suffer from a drastically changed water chemistry (assuming the water temperature doesn't change).

HTH
-Richer
 
Originally posted by NJ Devils Fan
Nononononononononono 99SH, that wasn't directed to you. Sorry. It's just to people who have tanks and don't do anything good for them.

oh, ok. I just couldn't tell. I have another question actually, where could I get information on crawfish?
 
AquariaCentral.com