dwarf shrimp versus non-planted tank

mattsfishtank

AC Members
Jan 1, 2008
21
0
0
Minnesota
I'm in the process of determining what I want to restock my 25 gallon bow front tank with, and I had a question regarding invertebrates and dwarf shrimp.

Will cherry shrimp or crystal red shrimp have any issues being in a tank that does not have any real plants?
 
Dwarf shrimp don't NEED planted tanks, but they are prefered. As long as it has plenty of places that the shrimp can climb on they should be fine.
 
Like most things, they feel more secure with cover, and plants provide that. They also tend to harbor the biofilm that shrimp graze on, though that can and does grow everywhere.
 
Non living decorations do not bother shrimp, As stated, they do need places to hide. Interestingly, shrimp with suitable hiding places will spend more time visible than those who don't feel comfortable. Also, you don't need to worry about fertilizers or CO2.

Personally, I have lightly planted tanks. That is, things like java moss and Marimo moss balls (which aren't moss).
 
I've contemplated adding a couple live plants into my tank, but I'm not sure I'd be successful growing them. I have no interest in redoing my gravel substrate, and I don't really like the look of floating plants. My light fixture only houses one 18" F15T8 "daylight" bulb and the housing doesn't have any reflective material inside.
 
If the light is bright enough to light up the tank for enjoyable viewing it is plenty bright enough to grow all but the most demanding plants. And I have grown them in substrates of consistency from fine sand to ecocomplete-style to quarter inch gravel, no worries. Watch the AC Marketplace until somebody is having a sell-off-the-clippings sale and dive in. Stem plants are probably easiest but leaf- bunches like Amazon swords likewise do well in moderate lighting and about any material deep enough to hold the roots in place.

Plants can have downsides, depending in large part on where you get them (applies both to stores and private sellers here): they can bring in algae and, most especially, pest snails. Best bet with sellers here is ask upfront if they have pond or ramshorns or malaysian trumpet snails in their tanks, and if so, avoid them. Snail eggs are incredibly sturdy and even if they are cleaned of all adults you will almost certainly get an outbreak. Also plants can make vacuuming around them difficult. But there is no question, in my mind anyway, that shrimp do better in tanks with plants than in those without, for reasons cited above.
 
AquariaCentral.com