friends without over crowding

jennypenny

AC Members
Oct 30, 2005
381
0
0
Athens, Ohio
Okay, I am happy to say that I just inherited a green swordtail and an albino cory. The swordtail, actually use to be mine. I had to give it to my parents while until I moved into my current home and put up my current tank. We don’t exactly live close to one another so I brought the fish home after the holiday. I took both, because they were being housed with goldfish. A less than ideal setup, but all my folks have at the moment. My new fish and their former tankmates have all been healthy (at least they look and act normally) for months. So, I did not bother setting up a Q-tank (I don’t have a proper set up yet anyway).

The cory seems to be excited as it investigates it’s new home. The swordtail is acting just a little on the timid side, but they have only been in there for a day.

Anywho, my question is who else should I add in order to keep everyone happy. There are already 4 platys in the tank (1 male and 3 female). I’m worried that the swordtail might start harassing the females unless I get him a girlfriend or two. What do you think is a minimum number of females I could add to the tank, and still avoid possible fish stress?

I also would like to get the cory a companion or two, but I can wait until I have the swordtails and platys figured out. He has been without for many months. So, I a few weeks more will hopefully not make a difference.

I think I have some room for adding fish, but it is only a ten gallon tank. I don’t need to go over board. I am planning another tank, but that may not happen for months. Any suggested stocking combos would be appreciated.
 
I wouldn't add anything until you get the bigger tank. Mixing swords and platies may result in some crosses--no matter how many girl swords you put in, the male will still be interested in the female platies, and the male platy will go after the female swords. Adding anything more than one or 2 cories will max out the 10, and waiting until a larger setup is available would benefit all the fish.
 
Well I would be happy to wait and see with the swordtail and platys, but my platy male already chases the females around fairly aggressively. I'm just worried that another male will cause too much stress. I have no plans to save babies. I know some may survive even without my protection, but crossberding is not my major concern.

If the females do show signs of extra stress what should I do, or how might I try to pervent extra stress untill I can move some of the fish. (Again I chose to take these fish because there was not a suitable tank for them at there previous home.)
 
the pnly method I would recommend to make your fish happier is to give them some more room. You could consider changing your 10 gallon for a 20 galloner. It should not be so expensive, and there you'll have enough space to add a couple corycats.

About the platies and the swordatail, leave them like that. They'll eventually start mating and you don't need more: 2 males and 3 fems should do fine.

Your focus of atention should be directed over the size tank issue.
 
Well, maybe I'm just asking the wrong question, or maybe there is no good soultion. I am working on another tank, but it may be awhile before it can be happy home for any fish. I'm honestly only concerned with the next couple of months. I'm focused on a temperary situation.
If you think the 2-3 male to female ratio will be okay, I won't stress over anymore. I'll just keep an extra eye on everybody.
 
Adding some plants (live or fake) or other decorations to give the girls some place to duck behind and get away from the boys if it gets to be 'too much' will help.
 
That should be doable, thanks for the suggestion.
 
AquariaCentral.com