You can certainly try them both. You might ask local reefers if they are interested in trading the flower pot if you decide otherwise. They'd probably give you a better trade I'd think. I'd love to see a photo of yours by the way.
Well, after more hunting around and reading different websites about the flowerpot, I got scared of killing it, so I took it in to my fave FS. The owner is going to keep it for me and see if it starts to look better again. I think it was great when I got it this morning, but I handled it too much when I was trying to find a place to put it. :wall: :uhoh: So this is what it looked like before I took it in:
I wish I'd taken a pic of it before I took it out of the bag.

I'm rather mad at myself over this one because I know it's my fault it started looking bad. I was having a hard time finding a good spot for it and it kept tipping over on a rock and it fell to the bottom once and ugh. :wall:
However, all is not lost, my FS guy is really nice and is going to hold on to it for me in his gorgeous coral tank and he'll either give it back to me once it's looking better, if I want to attempt it again, or he'll sell it and give me a fish or credit on something else.
Also, the flowerpot appears to have left a baby behind in my tank! I found a teeny tiny ball that looks like an itty bitty version of the big one, except it was sitting in a little indention in a rock (one of the ones I tried to balance the big one on) and has all it's polyps opened and looking pretty!
Forgive the crappy quality please. My camera isn't good with macro shots. If I ever stop spending money on this hobby, I might get a new camera.
It wasn't a wasted trip to the FS! You know I couldn't leave empty handed! I had asked the owner to see if he could get a red spotted lawnmower blenny after seeing the normal one in Petco last week and then finding the red spotted one online. He already had it for me! This isn't the actual fish, but he's in my tank now and he's the cutest fish in the whole world! Errr, don't tell my Citron or my Diamond Goby I said that! :lipssealedsmilie:
Thanks for listening to me today and advising me and everything. See? I really do listen to you guys!
ummm, except for the uhhh, yah, no qt at the moment. :duh: In my defense, I had to give away my last small tank to help out a friend. I promise I'll get one soon!