hardscape placement opinons

[customdrum]

rescaping this 29g tank and wanted to hear thoughts on these wood placements.
trying alot of placements till i get it looking right then ill move onto plants

 

[red_wall]

I like 1-3 the best. The first is my favorite though.

 

[Hurley]

I like the last one the best because it looks like its part of the scape rather then just a piece of wood placed in the front of the tank. I love the branchy look in all of the layouts.

 

[Dr. Awkward]

I like the first one and last one, especially the last one because it keeps the front of the tank clear (for more plants!)

 

[Flamfish]

I agree with Hurley. I like the natural look and the last pic fits it.

 

[bitbot]

I vote for no 1.

 

[Carla G]

I like the first one.

Don't think you're getting a consensus here, lol.

 

[Zaffy]

2, then 1.

 

[andyjs]

I vote 2. I actually like having large objects breaking up the foreground because it looks more natural. In nature everything isn't always perfectly tiered by size

 

[customdrum]

thanks for the replys

i have it setup like the last pics now. the plants will be moved around some since i have sold some off today. so im not worried about them until i get the wood right,

i think the last 1 is the best looking in the pics and the 2nd 1 would look good in a much larger tank than this which im sure ill have later.