How fast do they grow?

jaylin

Don't ask if you don't want to know
Aug 14, 2005
519
0
0
Denver-ish Colorado.
Electric Yellow Cichlid - Labidochromis caeruleus

I'm curious to hear from people who keep these about how fast they grow?

Meaning, I saw a couple of these at a pet store that, at the moment could easily be kept in a 10 gal tank (they're smaller than your average platty right now), but how long would it be before they're needing more space? How long until they reach their full potential? Correct me if I'm wrong, but they get up to about 5" right?
 
5" is a good #. You should start them in a tank that they will grow into, not start them in a small tank then move them later. I have not kept yellows, but other mbunas I've had reached arround 5 inches in about 2 years (if memory serves correctly)
 
sumthin fishy said:
You should start them in a tank that they will grow into, not start them in a small tank then move them later.

What's the logic behind that?

By the way, these guys would grow into a 10 gal. Right now they are tiny, tiny.
 
You will be just fine starting them in a 10 gallon as long as you have good filtration and aeriation.
 
Well Jay, taking Bob's advice there, all ya need to do is take a look at his tank specs to decide if you want to take that advice or not, I wouldn't.

the 36gal:
Oscars get 12-13" in a year- year and a half given proper care
Texas get 10-12"
Your "african cichlids" well that tells us next to nothing, though I assume they are malawi species, which are completely incompatible with the Oscars and Texas as well as the Clown Loaches, and potentially the plecos.
Clown Loaches get 12" and need warm super clean water to stay healthy
The "plecos" which I assume are just your common ones, will easily get 16"+

Basically that tank is sick and shows absolutely no respect for the fish, IF all of them were compatible with each other you would easily need a MINIMUM of a 150gal to properly house them all.

the 10gal:
Chances are you either have a ghost or clown knife, the clowns get 30-36" easily in captivity, while Ghosts get to 19-20". Both compltely unsuited for a 10gal, in fact all knives shouldn't be kept in anything that small.

Again the "African cichlids" issue, most likely Malawis, nothing that is suitable or compatible with the knives or pelcos.

The plecos get 16"+ as I listed previously, and not suited for a 10gal.

Yet another grossly overstocked tank, no respect for the fish, and no notion of knowing anything about compatibility between species, let alone identifying them correctly. IF these species were compatible you would need a very large aquaria for a clownknife alone, 200gal+ and at least a 125gal with the ghost knife.


Jay, The logic behind starting them in a tank that will be suitable for their adult size is quite clear, you won't have to change tanks once they start to get larger for one, and as they mature (mind you they will get territorial and such long before reaching adult hood) they will have adaquate space to establish territories and lessen the chance of having issues around that in the future. IF all you can do is a 10gal, I would suggest looking at other species of fish to stock in it.
 
Now that is pretty judgemental NatakuTseng, how do you know my fish are not happy, you dont know a thing about my aquarium, like I am gonna spend a lot of money of fish just to abuse them. Maybe I dont like those boring understocked aquariums? Maybe you are the extreme?
 
I bought my electric yellows at around 1.5" to 2.0".
They grew up to 3" to 3.5" pretty darn fast!
I'd say within 2 - 3 months they got that big.
They were originally in a 10G, which is way too small but they are all in a 60G now.
They are all now about 4.0" to 4.5" now over the next two months, and they have been like this for the past month, so I think their growth is slowing down?
So I'd say they would easily outgrow the 10G in 2 - 3 months!
 
bob1962 said:
Now that is pretty judgemental NatakuTseng, how do you know my fish are not happy, you dont know a thing about my aquarium, like I am gonna spend a lot of money of fish just to abuse them. Maybe I dont like those boring understocked aquariums? Maybe you are the extreme?
Had there been no explination as to why they won't be happy I might agree. But facts were stated and they are correct. Will you be getting a 100+gallon tank for any of these fish when need be, or will they be stuck in a 12" deep aquarium when they are 14, 16, 20 inches long. Will you wait untill they have developed health problems to move them, or are you currently saving for that new tank?

Jaylin-You can find some rationale in what I said yesterday in my :rant2: above. While it seemms fine for them to be in there now, when they mature there may be health problems resulting from stunted growth, and aslo as stated, territorial issues. Since they will not get over 12", there is less an issue of them not being able to turn arround, but not having enough room to exercise is the point there. If thats where you have them now(in a 10) fine, but start saving up for a bigger tank so you can move them soon.
 
sumthin fishy said:
Had there been no explination as to why they won't be happy I might agree...........

Well the topic really had nothing to do with my aquarium. I was raising tropical fish when I was knee high. I had 7 Texas Cichlids in a 20 Gallon tank back then, they all did fine on an old bubble filtration tank.

You will be just fine starting them in a 10 gallon as long as you have good filtration and aeriation.

I am just posting my experience with aquariums
 
AquariaCentral.com