Who told you 5 watt's per Gallon? a heater chosen should be 2-3 watts per gallon to provide adequate heat. Personally my own preference is to undersize the heater as this lessens the risk of the unit malfunctioning and cooking the tank. as an alternative you can install a pair of smaller heaters rather than a single or large one. for example a 50 G would usually use a 100 - 150 watt heater, but 2 50 or 75 watt units would do a better job. In Gumby's case he has a 15 G tank and he would most definetly use a 50 watt heater as the tank is not large enough to worry about drastic temp. swings.