Is it necessary to quarantine shrimp/snails?

LMOUTHBASS

My hypocrisy goes only so far
Jun 17, 2003
1,326
1
38
Boston , MA
Visit site
Real Name
Mark
I am thinking of picking up some shrimp I'm big on quarantining new fish but is this necessary with shrimp or even snails? Is there anything they could bring into the tank that would effect the tank's ecosystem?


Thanks


PS - if anyone could reccomend some algae eaters that will eat the green type of the sides of my tank or even the brownish/moroon colored stuff on my leaves I would appreciate it!

I have some ottos, a clown pleco, and a SAE but they're not making a dent - i'm thinking of getting more ottos but i know they mostly eat the diatoms (sp?) or beginning phases of brown algae


Thanks again
 
i would love to have some cool shrimp in my tank. what kind are you going for? do you know of any that are kinda of big that can live in a freshwater tank?
 
butterflylove said:
i would love to have some cool shrimp in my tank. what kind are you going for? do you know of any that are kinda of big that can live in a freshwater tank?

It depends what you're looking for - an algae-eater? A purely "decorative" fixture? Both? Will it go into a planted tank or a fauna-oriented system? A community tank? Are you looking into a centerpiece for a species setup?

See www.petshrimp.com - the most well-informed hub of hobbyist discussion devoted to these creatures (look under "Shrimp Varieties" for a diverse selection of species).

Another consideration is what you mean by "kinda big" - are you looking for creatures within the two-inch range ("Amano"/"Yamato" shrimp and "flower"/"bamboo" shrimp), or nine-inch behemoths (African fan shrimp, Atyopsis gabonensis, a peaceful filter feeder, if somewhat grotesque for some tastes). Conversely, some shrimp grow to over twenty-six inches in length and kill everything other organism that enters the tank [African cichlids and gars are typically easy prey], notably Macrobrachium rosenbergii - the "giant Malaysian prawn" and a few other "lunkers" of that immensely varied genus). I must say that large Macrobrachium easily tame, and come the closest to true pet status amongst all shrimp (in addition to being behaviorally fascinating in their own right); the four-inch forms are more suitable for the means of the typical aquarist, and there are numerous peaceful detritus feeders (e.g., "Indian pearl shrimp").

Shrimp range from the diminutive, exquisitely colored "crystal red", Neocaridina sp. (see http://www.amazon-exotic-import.de/Gallerie/Garnelen/Bilder/Red Crystal 01.jpg) to two-foot tankbusters (see http://www.aqua-addiction.com/forums/index.php?act=Attach&type=post&id =24468, http://www.msstate.edu/dept/crec/prawn.jpg and http://southcenters.osu.edu/aqua/intro/sld013.htm).

The commonly available feeder "ghost shrimp" (Palaemonetes sp.), in a pinch, make fascinating aquarium subjects as well.
 
Last edited:
Going back to the original topic:

Unless you already have crustaceans in the tank you intend to introduce new shrimp to, it is not *essential* to quarantine (shrimp-fish and shrimp-mollusk disease transmission is rare), but I would do so just the same for purposes of general vitality confirmation. In the event that shrimp are already present, I would consider quarantine procedures mandatory.

As for your algae problem, kill two proverbial birds with the single stone of some Amano (after the renowned “Nature Aquarium” designer) algae-eating shrimp (a.k.a. Yamato numa-ebi [literally, “Japanese swamp shrimp”], Yamato shrimp), Caridina japonica, which hails from the subtropical freshwaters of Japan (it tolerates wide temperature variation and will thrive in both temperate outdoor pools and tropical aquaria), reaching around 6cm/2" in captivity. This shrimp primarily grazes on algae (of all sorts, including blue-green “hair”, “carpet”, and rusty-brown diatomaceous growth, to give a selection), and is capable of clearing every surface of visible algal growth very soon after introduction to a tank. However, if algae is scarce, it may turn its attention to soft plants, but this is only usually noticeable if there is a very large group of shrimp in the aquarium; algae wafers and Spirulina-based foods can be used to supplement the diet under such conditions. C. japonica tolerates most all types of water (even light brackish), but its larvae require estuarine to full marine salinity to develop proceeding to adulthood in freshwater. “Amanos” are most commonly kept in heavily planted aquaria as a natural algae combatant; a fairly large “herd” of shrimp is required to keep algae completely in check. The species cohabits well with fish, provided that they are relatively small and non-predatory.

Join the discussion board of www.petshrimp.com for any further inquiries – I have found response to be prompt and well-informed.

I know that several species of the Caridina/Neocaridina clade may rival or exceed Amanos in algae-eating potential and range [but, being considerably smaller, must be stocked at a proportionally greater density] (look into “Shrimp Varieties” of the linked website under the heading of “Algae-Eating Shrimp”).
 
Last edited:
Great information thanks veneer - I would like to try some amano shrimp but I do fear they will fall prey to my angel fish ,clown or khuli loaches - I think my gourami my might a snack out of them too - whatcha think?
 
Cichlids and loaches are always iffy as crustacean cohabitants; Amanos can fend for themselves but will probably be continually harrassed if not quickly consumed in the setup you mentioned (I have not had, as of yet, any personal experience with Amanos in a community system).
 
AquariaCentral.com