Laterite - catlitter?

  • Get the NEW AquariaCentral iOS app --> http://itunes.apple.com/app/id1227181058 // Android version will be out soon!

tetra_girl

AC Members
Dec 21, 2002
41
0
0
Vancouver, BC
Visit site
Kitty litter is laterite, but using it in aquariums is definitely a hotly debated topic.

I'll admit, I am a newbie at plants (am on my first planted tank :)), but I did a fair amount of research before getting it started and found some interesting information that you may find interesting too.

This link claims to explain how the whole crazy thing got started. ;)

http://www.nanfa.org/archive/nanfa01/nanfamay01/0137.html


Here are a few links that go over various substrate materials (and are decidedly not in favor of Kitty litter)

http://www.csd.net/~cgadd/aqua/art_plant_substrate.htm
http://www.animalnetwork.com/fish2/aqfm/1998/jan/aquatic/default.asp

The problem with most kitty litter is that there are additives like the algon site says (perfumes, clumping additives etc). The first thing is to find a brand with no additives- ingredients are listed on the bag and it will say if it's 100% laterite clay. Some of the generic or 'natural' brands are without additives (Wal-Mart Special Kitty litter seems to be popular).

However, many people are still wary of using even additive free kitty litter mainly for the reasons sited in the 2nd link- it was intended for a cat box and quality control was not set up for the presence of aquarium unsafe materials specifically.

Another reason I have read is that kitty litter is not as nutrient rich as aquarium laterite. Aquarium laterite is usually reddish due to good iron content etc. Kitty litter is baked and gray, and has lost some of it's nutrients.

On the other hand, here is a blurb by someone who did use kitty litter and supposedly did a chemical analysis

http://www.thekrib.com/Plants/Fertilizer/substrate-jamie.html

There are tons of info/arguments for both sides, so I think it's a personal decision.

Hope you found this interesting. :p

Oh, and by the way I have bottom layer of mixed vermiculite and kitty litter substrate, and my amazon swords just love it. :D
 

RTR

AC Members
Oct 5, 1998
5,806
0
0
Braddock Heights, MD
Kitty litter is NOT laterite. The kitty litter used as aquarium substrate should be baked clay, but not all clay is laterite. Laterite is a highly leached clay formed in the tropics over geologic time. Laterite is rich in iron and aluminum compounds, kitty litter may or or may not have detectable or usable iron.

The ref's cited by tetra_girl above are good - but please do note that none of these consider kitty litter to be laterite - is is not.

Laterite is not nutrient rich, not even the Flourite commercial product - other than in iron. It is good at binding for ready exchange many nutrients from the water column. That plus the lifetime supply of iron is its value.
 

tetra_girl

AC Members
Dec 21, 2002
41
0
0
Vancouver, BC
Visit site
I wonder if the term laterite is used loosely outside the aquarium industry. :confused:

The bag of plain kitty litter I purchased and used actually said "LATERITE CLAY", no chemical clumping agents, etc. I can't remember what brand exactly (just remember it was a blue bag I got at the grocery store), but it absolutely said "laterite clay" as the 100% ingredient.

Perhaps it is a broad term for any kind of weathered clay?

I used to be in geology in school and though I've forgotten almost everything :( I do recall that there were very specific criteria/specifications to classing various things like loam and even sand and gravel, which did not always match up with the common terms used in say landscaping etc.

I dunno?
 

tetra_girl

AC Members
Dec 21, 2002
41
0
0
Vancouver, BC
Visit site
I found the answer! :)

Turns out you're more right than me RTR. Did some digging around and the definitive answer is that MOST clay based cat litter uses bentonite clay- not laterite.

But there are SOME litters that use other various types of clays/substrate materials such as Fuller's Earth and laterite, so I just happened to stumble upon a couple brands that actually do use laterite (or at least that's what they said on the bags).

Here is a link to a litter producer that also says bentonite clays are the preferred clay, and gives a chemical analysis.
http://abone.turk.net/tulumen/Products&Packages.htm

It turns out Koi pond fishkeepers have been having the same "to use kitty litter or not" debate, lol. :p

Apparently in their niche, they use montmorillonite clay for ion exchange/to add nutrients etc and montmorillonite is basically the same as bentonite clays.

Here is where they ended up http://www.koivet.com/catlitter.html

Here is a more complete run down of substrates including all these clays
http://www.google.ca/search?q=cache:qBC_1bL3gooC:home.infinet.net/teban/jamie.htm+bentonite+laterite+cat+litter&hl=en&ie=UTF-8

I also got out my old books and here is the textbook definition of laterite:

"Laterite is a soil formed in the tropics where chemical weathering is intense and leaching of soluble minerals is complete. Such soils are red......and are composed largely of aluminum hydroxides, iron oxides, and clay minerals; even quartz, a chemically stable mineral, is generally leached out.

Although laterites support lush vegetation, they are not very fertile. The native vegetation is sustained by nutrients derived mostly from the surface layer of organic matter, but little humus is present in the soil itself because bacterial action destroys it. When such soils are cleared of their native vegetation, the existing surface accumulations of organic matter is rapidly oxidized, and there is little to replace it. Consequently, when societies practicing slash and burn agriculture clear these soils, they can raise crops for only a few years at best. Then the soil is completely depleted of plant nutrients, the clay rich laterite bakes brick hard in the tropical sun, and the farmers move on to another area where the process is repeated."

It goes on to say that Bauxite (aluminum ore), forms with laterite who's parent material was rich in aluminum can be found in Arkansas, Alabama and Georgia, which had tropical climates about 50 million years ago, but is mainly imported from currently tropical climates.

So there you have it. MOST clay cat litter is bentonite clay, not laterite. But both have desirable properties.

Back to work now.
:p
 
zoomed.com
hikariusa.com
aqaimports.com
Store