I've referred to that site a few times, but it's hard to get a real feel for a store if there are only a couple reviews. What I like to do is plan "field trips" where I'll pick a nearby city and chart out an efficent route to hit several fish stores in one day...some things you just gotta experience yourself (bring a styrofoam fish box and mucho mula).
Its rather refreshing to see other people do this

Brian