Fishfriend (and/or Zaffy) - Going to count him/them innocent. If evil, FF would already have known roles for ALL the players (innocents and scum) so a game mod slip about roles would not compromise the game for him.
"Kasta" thing - As it was my name mispelled on the list, twice, I noticed it. Piglet didn't know how to spell it.
Usrname - Posted right after that. I basically ignored it when I read this. It wasn't all that funny but I could see he was trying to be funny about it. No big deal.
Bally - Have read through other comments posted about Bally. She clearly didn't catch the misspelling of my name, then overreacted to Username's joke. Given her on and off play and that it lead to a Day 1 vote for UN from her, I can understand both her misunderstanding and why she voted that way. What I don't understand is how that
makes her evil.
In the last game with Bally, she got kinda flustered, looked scummy as scum can be, made a confusing/pointless last-minute vote switch, then eventually UD'd the next night. Yet, she was innocent the whole time.
Lady G - You asked about me asking Wizard about voting you. Don't understand your confusion there. He voted early to avoid UD... no problem. I didn't question why voted then. I asked how he picked you. I assume random somehow but he had 7 names to pick from. How/why did he choose yours? <-- that was my question.
I knew Wizard wouldn't be back before nightfall but didn't know he wouldn't be alive after nightfall to answer my post.
DD - Made a post about me for low participation and not posting Kashta-like. That seemed really weird coming from her. Regular members in the game might question it because they may not have noticed I'm a lot less active at the site and mafia games since I stopped working from home using remote access to do my job. But DD is not a regular member - and she knows my job changed last November. For DD to question this in a game to make me "appear" suspicious to everyone else because of it is very peculiar, IMO.
Pappy - DD and Pappy joke back and forth with each other most games on Day 1. They also enjoy voting each other whenever they do. That's normal. I wouldn't have wondered anything had they done this like usual. Even a "random" Day 1 on DD from Pappy....... I would've ignored that. What made Pappy's comment curious for me this time was his wording and emphasis (italics)... saying DD wanting to fight with him was a red flag... etc. Well, everyone knows DD wants to start a play-fight with Pappy. Pappy wants to start a play-fight with DD. DD not wanting to do this; now THAT would have been a red flag. Pappy says this was just joking around, and maybe it was. I'm just not convinced. Looked more to me like Pappy wanted to get us looking at DD this time in a way he could later just shrug off as one of their usual joke spats later on if someone else voted her. Either way, maybe it makes a difference; maybe it doesn't. Who knows? There was just nothing else going on in the game yet so instead of making a purely random vote, I voted Pappy when I had to place my vote so early.
As it is now, my main concern about Pappy is him pushing the case against Bally to a vote. I totally disagree with the Bally-must-be-evil theory for her UN vote night 1 (see above). So this makes me suspect Pappy over for his vote on her.
I still need to vote myself. Right now, I'm trying to decide between Lady G, DD, and Pappy. I'll still be at work during nightfall but I'm oping I'll be able to get back to vote.
If I don't make it, then I'll obviously UD instead... but, at worst, you'll all still have my thoughts from this post as input for tomorrow.
"Kasta" thing - As it was my name mispelled on the list, twice, I noticed it. Piglet didn't know how to spell it.
Usrname - Posted right after that. I basically ignored it when I read this. It wasn't all that funny but I could see he was trying to be funny about it. No big deal.
Bally - Have read through other comments posted about Bally. She clearly didn't catch the misspelling of my name, then overreacted to Username's joke. Given her on and off play and that it lead to a Day 1 vote for UN from her, I can understand both her misunderstanding and why she voted that way. What I don't understand is how that
makes her evil.
In the last game with Bally, she got kinda flustered, looked scummy as scum can be, made a confusing/pointless last-minute vote switch, then eventually UD'd the next night. Yet, she was innocent the whole time.
Lady G - You asked about me asking Wizard about voting you. Don't understand your confusion there. He voted early to avoid UD... no problem. I didn't question why voted then. I asked how he picked you. I assume random somehow but he had 7 names to pick from. How/why did he choose yours? <-- that was my question.
I knew Wizard wouldn't be back before nightfall but didn't know he wouldn't be alive after nightfall to answer my post.
DD - Made a post about me for low participation and not posting Kashta-like. That seemed really weird coming from her. Regular members in the game might question it because they may not have noticed I'm a lot less active at the site and mafia games since I stopped working from home using remote access to do my job. But DD is not a regular member - and she knows my job changed last November. For DD to question this in a game to make me "appear" suspicious to everyone else because of it is very peculiar, IMO.
Pappy - DD and Pappy joke back and forth with each other most games on Day 1. They also enjoy voting each other whenever they do. That's normal. I wouldn't have wondered anything had they done this like usual. Even a "random" Day 1 on DD from Pappy....... I would've ignored that. What made Pappy's comment curious for me this time was his wording and emphasis (italics)... saying DD wanting to fight with him was a red flag... etc. Well, everyone knows DD wants to start a play-fight with Pappy. Pappy wants to start a play-fight with DD. DD not wanting to do this; now THAT would have been a red flag. Pappy says this was just joking around, and maybe it was. I'm just not convinced. Looked more to me like Pappy wanted to get us looking at DD this time in a way he could later just shrug off as one of their usual joke spats later on if someone else voted her. Either way, maybe it makes a difference; maybe it doesn't. Who knows? There was just nothing else going on in the game yet so instead of making a purely random vote, I voted Pappy when I had to place my vote so early.
As it is now, my main concern about Pappy is him pushing the case against Bally to a vote. I totally disagree with the Bally-must-be-evil theory for her UN vote night 1 (see above). So this makes me suspect Pappy over for his vote on her.
I still need to vote myself. Right now, I'm trying to decide between Lady G, DD, and Pappy. I'll still be at work during nightfall but I'm oping I'll be able to get back to vote.
If I don't make it, then I'll obviously UD instead... but, at worst, you'll all still have my thoughts from this post as input for tomorrow.
