new aquarium -- dandruff looking stuff -- what is it?

gingerinaustin

AC Members
Apr 11, 2007
205
0
0
Hi all--
I have a new 55 gallon aquarium (roughly 4 weeks old) with a Penguin 350 power filter. It's still in the process of cycling. I condition my tap water with Prime. I test the water every day; after this morning's 25% water change today, the readings were:
ammonia 0
total and free chlorine 0
nitrite .5
nitrate 10
total alkalinity 80
pH 6.4 (unusually low for the tap water in this area, but the reading may be off due to the low total alkalinity)
total hardness 120
I have a gourami, 3 platies, 3 mollies and 7 cardinal tetras in the tank and they are all doing fabulously (one of the platies got her fin nipped by the gourami, but it's growing back). I've never had an ammonia spike, it's always read 0. I've taken a water sample to the LFS for testing each week and they get the same test results as mine.

When I first set up the aquarium, I rinsed the gravel very well. Decorations include black rocks, white gravel, fake plants and a big piece of driftwood that has been soaked in water and scrubbed down well. As soon as the test strips started showing nitrite (about 2 1/2 weeks in), I started doing water changes. With each water change, I've rinsed out the filter cartridges in tank water and I've vacuumed 1/4-1/3 of the gravel. The Visitherm Stealth heater maintains the temperature at a steady 78-79 degrees according to the digital thermometer (during water changes, I'm careful to make sure the new water's the same temperature). And, we have been very, VERY careful not to overfeed the fish.

For about a week and a half, I've noticed a fair amount of particulate matter floating in the tank. It looks like dandruff (I have a black background on the back of the tank). It's not the same sort of cloudiness I experienced on the second or third day after we added the first few fish. The water is clear except for this dandruff-like material floating around in the tank. We cut the amount of food we've been giving the fish in half for the past few days (we feel like we're starving the poor lil puppies-they all do the "feed me!" dance if we get anywhere near the tank) and it hasn't make a difference in the appearance of this dandruff-like particulate matter. It doesn't get better after water changes.

What the heck is this stuff? Will it go away after the tank is fully cycled? Is there some treatment I can add to the tank or some sort of different filter media I can use to get rid of it?

And one other question (while I have your attention) -- should I add something to bring up the total alkalinity of the tank a notch? I add baking soda to my hot tub when the total alkalinity drops to 80 or below, but I'm guessing it's not that easy to remedy in an aquarium with fish.

Thank you!!
 
ok no ph changing stuff, many people would be jealous of that ph (ahem me) since its acidic. The tetras will apreciate it but maybe not so much the livebearers but they are adaptable.

Search planaria on google or something

how much do you feed??? You have nitrite which is highly toxic to your fish, do 50% water changes daily until its at a constant 0, your not done cycling and you already have these fragile fish. Does your tap have nitrite?
 
Musho, thanks for responding. My question was about trying to bring up the total alkalinity, not altering the pH. What is your opinion on adding something to bring up the total alkalinity (buffering capacity of the water)? I read in my test kit materials that if the total alkalinity is too low, the pH reading will be thrown off. I don't want to alter the pH; I was asking if it would be wise to try raising the total alkalinity (maybe the pH isn't really that low, maybe I'm getting false low pHs because the buffering capacity is too low).

I feed a very tiny pinch of flake food in the morning (it's gone in a minute or less) and a half a very tiny pinch n the evening. (I read mollies like to eat smaller amounts more often).

From what I read, planaria are worms; they wriggle and crawl. The stuff I'm talking about in my tank looks like inert white dandruff-like specks. It's isn't wriggling or crawling. It doesn't look like worms. It looks nothing like this or this. It looks more like the stuff swirling around Jack Nance at end of Eraserhead

Right, the tank is not cycled. My question was if this stuff would go away after it was cycled (i.e., is it a byproduct of some cycling process).

My untreated tap water has no nitrite (I just tested it). Wouldn't the Prime sequester any nitrite present, anyway?

ok no ph changing stuff, many people would be jealous of that ph (ahem me) since its acidic. The tetras will apreciate it but maybe not so much the livebearers but they are adaptable.

Search planaria on google or something

how much do you feed??? You have nitrite which is highly toxic to your fish, do 50% water changes daily until its at a constant 0, your not done cycling and you already have these fragile fish. Does your tap have nitrite?
 
Last edited:
It could just be things that are coming out of the substrate because your filter may be causing a big current. I'm not sure. I have some of that, sorta, not dandruff looking, but it floats around. Water changes help.
 
bringing up the total alkalinity would end up raising the pH. I dont know what the flecks are besides planaria, you arent over feeding so dont worry. What test kit are you using?
 
hitman, thanks for your response. I have not found water changes to help my situation. My filter cartridges are comprised of blue foam and activated charcoal--nothing white.

It could just be things that are coming out of the substrate because your filter may be causing a big current. I'm not sure. I have some of that, sorta, not dandruff looking, but it floats around. Water changes help.
 
Musho, I am using the Mardel 5-in-1 test strips, expiration date 8/2008. The readings I am getting are the same as the readings the LFS store gets on my water sample with their titration reagent test kits each week, so I'm pretty confident of their accuracy (and frankly, if it required more than a dip of a test strip, the testing probably wouldn't get done every day--that is the reality of my life!).
 
I used the Mardel 5-in-1 and then I used the API Freshwater Master Test Kit and the results were different. I would trust the liquid tests over the strips.
 
Does it look like bonafide flakes of dead skin, or are they just tiny particles. I notice you have a white substrte - it's probably the smaller, lighter pieces being swept around by your current.
 
I had what may be the same stuff. I use a fluval 305 and I had the same problem until I added filter pads that did finer filtering. This only cut it down though.

Q
 
AquariaCentral.com