As a classroom teacher in a rough school, I have to say that I agree with both the respect aspect and the inability to discipline the kids. I have a class full of kids whose family dynamic is the Norteno/Sureno gang life. Parents, friends, brothers and sisters in prison for violent crimes, or in a cemetary because of the result. Most of the kids respond to the no bull****, dead honest approach. They may not do every assignment, but they come to class and say good morning and talk about their lives. There are, however, kids who need a stronger hand. Detention is not a deterent to their rudeness and abusive behavior, yet it is the only option available to me. They continue with the behavior, despite kindness, honesty and acceptance, even when their best bud flourishes in the same environment. Do I honestly believe that a spanking *shudder* or a smack upside the head from a school employee would help? No. But these kids need something that I can't give them in my room, or on my campus. Compared to what their lives can be like ouside of school, what goes on inside is child's play. It leaves the teachers feeling helpless, because our entire lives are devoted to these kids. There is no easy answer to this problem. If there were, every child would graduate high school and move on to have a successful, balanced life in whatever path their life takes. They would know that teachers are there because they care more than words could express, and that all we want is for them to live out there dreams as respectful, responsible community members.......