Placement of HOB filter

Hydro

AC Members
Oct 31, 2003
64
0
0
Manitoba, Canada
Visit site
For a 10g with an AC Mini filter, would it be better to place the filter towards a corner of the tank or to slide it towards the middle of the tank? I would think it would yield more efficient cicurlation of the entire tank if it's near the middle as opposed to near one corner. Make sense?

Where do you usually put your HOB?
 
I would put it in the middle so that flow can kind of tumble both ways...

flow.jpg
 
As I am interested in the same issue, I was wondering: what do you do when the openings in the tank cover are smaller than the HOB? Or if you wish to place it in a spot where there's no opening at all?
 
There are variables to this answer, so I accept no liability, and suggest you look at things closely. With my big tank the rim that is designed to hold the lid got in the way of my HOB's, I simply cut it to fit removing as little material as I could. In essence, the inside lip is there for the lid only and not for support of the tank, the center brace and the rim that goes over the glass are critical.

With aa 10g the only thing that should ever be in your way is the hood/lid, so placement on them is a matter of adjusting the back lip of the lid.
BTW: I don't know how other people cut Thermo-setting plastics but I use a small soldering Iron, with a new tip. It goes through plastic like butter, and leaves a rounded edge that won't catch or hurt anything.

As far as placement, if the filter will fit somewhere that I don't want it, I re-adjust my thinking. I am a circulation fanatic, so I have an RFUG in every tank right now. and I can put a heater and hob any where in the tank and get good circulation because of the RFUG flow. Without an RFUG, I would suggest placing things that create flow like you heater, hob, or powerhead the best you can figuring out flow is fairly simple, just feed some sinking granules right before a water ghange. watch where the granules go in the tank and you'll know if you have any significant dead spot. then vaccum them out immediatly so they don't cause other problems. Almost every thing in a tank affects flow in some way, and a little experimentation will allow you to figure things out.
 
I have 2 hob's on my 29 gallon... one on each end. There was only one opening in my tank lid for a hob, so I used a pair of wire cutters and a pair of scissors and cut another opening... took me an hour and a half.

If I only had one filter, I'd probably put it in the middle for maximum flow/circulation...

~Tara
 
Unless an HOB is somewhat undersized for the tank it's on, I have a hard time believing the placement is that critical. Try putting an HOB on a bare tank filled with water. Add a couple drops of food coloring or malachite green (ich medicine) to the filter well and watch the dispersion of the color. If the filter is undersized, you may have some dead spots, but generally I'd expect that you'd see uniformity in the color of the water in just a few minutes.

Jim
 
I'll report the results if people are interested.

Someone always is. I learn from everyone every time I come here.

Just an Fyi on the dead spot concept, Decor tank size and placement all have an effect. an empty tank won't typically have dead spots even with an undersized filter, a decorated tank may have depending on size location etc of decor. An easy test is a thermometer as well (assuming the tank and the room have different temps) you can see where good circulation and bad circulation are with a thermometer as well, but not nearly as easily as food coloring or debris will show it.
 
AquariaCentral.com