Smaller schooling fishes for hardwater tank

toffee

AC Members
Oct 30, 2005
58
2
8
Need some small (2"-4") schooling fishes for my big (180g) tank. Water is really hard (ph 8, gh & kh close to 300) so I don't think the tetras would be suitable candidates.

I am thinking of something like 30-50 of them, any suggestion?
 
barbs but not sure
 
Zebra Danios? I have really hard water as well, and mine do fine.
 
I wouldn't worry about the tetras too much, they adapt, usually, quite readily. I had glo-lights in those conditions for close to a year before I moved and they were always vibrant and healthy. I can't say if it effects them long term, but hardness and pH generally only effect things like spawning abilities. Some fish which are wild caught don't adapt well either. However, I think keeping all other conditions healthy (good temp, waterchanges, etc) is a lot more important in keeping them.

Otherwise, the barbs suggested may work, depending on what you have (the only peaceful, non-largish one that comes to my mind is a cherry which I have heard do not shoal well). Guppies form loose shoals, but IME, the males hang out with each other a lot. Wild-type guppies (feeders) or endlers may be another good option as they will be smaller and won't hog the tank ... but, IME, a fairly decent shoal only happens when the shoal is all male with the guppies... I am unfamiliar with endlers.
 
I think that any small schooling fish would be fine, fw fish adapt really well to differing water conditions.

What about livebearers, like guppies?
 
Just make sure to do a slow acclimation. Also check to see what the water conditions are at your LFS. Chances are they aren't that different than yours. If you go with tetras stick to hardier varieties liek silver tip, emporer, head and tail light or with barbs think about cherry barbs which are ever so colourful and if kept in a large group not too aggressive.
 
They get closer to the 4" mark, but my scissortails are the best schoolers I have in my 180. I think there are only 10 or 12 of them, but they almost always stick together. Very pretty irridescent color in the right light/angle
 
I currently have some swordtails and mollies, they are nice and colorful but hardly school.
 
AquariaCentral.com