Snail free plants

Phil22

AC Members
Apr 9, 2007
258
0
0
The plants sold at PetSmart claim to be snail free. Are they really? Anyone have any experience with them?
Thanks
 
Yes petco/petsmart sell plants that are snail free. Be careful though some of them are not real aquatic plants.
 
The ones at my PetSmart had snails. I could see them on the plants and in the water in the store. I'm pretty sure that's the reason I have snails in my tank, but the plants weren't a bad price and I couldn't ever have enough plants. Anyway, as long as I don't overfeed, the snails aren't a big problem. They actually help clean up the dead plant matter.
 
I bought 3-4 plants from petsmart and had no snails. If you definitly don't want snails then you should quarantine or soak the plants to prevent it. Regardless of what a store claims, it's your responisblity to keep your tank in the condition you want it.
 
lol @ snail free...was this a specific store that made this claim or is it on the website? We definitely have snails in our store, they drive me crazy. We even tried moving all of our mystery snails to the plant tank to treat the fish tank for snails and then moved them back and the little buggers are still there. If you search the forum theres a way to clean plants, I'd rely on that.
 
I used the alum treatment, like 1 tbsp per gallon. I let it sit for 2 hours and 1.5 baby snails survived. I say 1.5 because 1 was dead but seemed to die after I added the plant. I suggest letting it sit longer than 2 hours for complete snail control.
 
I was referring to the ones that come in individual containers...not from a tank (like Mgamer indicated). The container itself says they are snail free. But you're right, they don't seem to be plants I see mentioned on this site.
Thanks for the replys.
 
Impudence12 said:
I used the alum treatment, like 1 tbsp per gallon. I let it sit for 2 hours and 1.5 baby snails survived. I say 1.5 because 1 was dead but seemed to die after I added the plant. I suggest letting it sit longer than 2 hours for complete snail control.

Um, yeah, the alum treatment is for 2 days. See below.

A 2-day soak in 1 tbsp/gallon of alum (buy it at drug stores) is good for killing snails and their eggs.
From: http://faq.thekrib.com/plant-qa.html
 
Last edited:
AquariaCentral.com