what cichlid is the nastyest?

As a general rule, any game fish legally caught of legal size is the property of the person who caught it. All laws aside from length season liscence etc. apply to the regulation of commercial sale, and trapping/ netting. For instance we often use Bluegill for Catfish bait, it is legal as long as we catch the bluegill on a rod and reel. we can't buy them, and we can't net or trap them. It is still always a good idea to check with your local DNR before taking home a native fish. Now back to the subject, if you are looking for a pure wicked nasty fish, my vate goes to the bluegill, they are very similar to most cihlids, but downright nasty, they will beat up bass, sunfish and even channel cats of similar size, they are as dirty as any cichlid ever bred, so be prepared to do lots of maintenace. I have seen several of my friends wreck really nice tanks with the addition of a bluegill. I am not suggesting you try it but if you want a nasty dude, go catch a bluegill.
 
I am sure this fish is not a cichlid but the snakehead is nasty! Will even attack people. Once they outgrow tanks or the cost to feed them people will even feed them small rodents, mice, rats or even rabbits. Some serious teeth can do some damage to almost anything.
 
imo the meanest cichlid by far is Parachromis Dovii (wolf cichlid) these fish can reach 27" and r killers. large mouth full of big teeth.
close seconds r Nandopsis Umbriferus, N. Haitiensis, N. Beani. these fish r incredibly aggressive. they will attack u through the glass. and with out a doubt in my mind these cichlids would destroy any other cichlid out there.
the meanest rift lake cichlid imo and ime is Neolamprologus Brichardi. i have heard stories of them killing groups of Neetroplus Nematopus. meanest riftlaker and maybe all of africa.
the meanest african cichlid is Hemichromis Elongatus (5 spot jewel) these fish only get 4.5" but r EXTREMELY AGGRO!!!!!.
but u r right Dean, none of the cichlids can compete with the arrowhead puffer (tetradon suvattii) those guys r STRAIGHT KILLERS!!!! they can kill red bellies and other pygocentrus piranhas, but it would be fare game for a serrasalmus piranha like S. Rhombeus (black piranha) which no cichlid not even the dovii can hang with the black piranha imo.
these r just my opinions from personal experience and with talking to other fish keepers.
 
Peacock bass I believe are cichlids (think I read it somewhere) anyway, I don't think a peacock bass could stand up to a Dovii (isn't it ironic that their scienctific name means "Peaceful Dove" lol thats a riot) Doviis get almost as large as peacocks, and have a mouth full of teeth, and a lot more attitude. Though not a cichlid I think a Muskellunge would put all these guys to shame, and of course there is always the African Tiger fish.
 
AquariaCentral.com