what fish go with bala sharks

tottenchris

Mud is fun!
Nov 30, 2006
298
0
0
37
Kalamazoo, Mi
i just started my freshwater tank and i have 1 pleco and 3 small bala sharks in a 30gal tank. i need to know what to do next in the terms of new fish. im hoping to add new fish in next week somtime. i now about the cycle and that has nearly completed. thanks.
 
Last edited:
In terms of what to do next with fish...

Determine if you have a common pleco; if so, take it back, it gets way to big for that size tank.

Ditto on the balas.

Research and post what kind of fish you like and you will get some good stocking recommendations.
 
to begin with, bala 'sharks' grow to a foot at maturity. that makes them ultimately much too large for your 30 gallon tank. moreover, these fish should be maintained in groups of 4-6 and that makes them even more inappropriate for your 30 gallon tank. ditto rbishop on the pleco.

pick some fish that you like that only grow to about 3 inches and c'mon back.
 
i just started my freshwater tank and i have 1 pleco and 3 small bala sharks in a 30gal tank. i need to know what to do next in the terms of new fish. im hoping to add new fish in next week somtime. i now about the cycle and that has nearly completed. thanks.
:eek:

Did the place you purchased the fish from know the size of tank you had? If they did the first thing I would do next is take them back and never take their advice without first researching. I have had bala's in small tanks but this was for a VERY TEMP situation. I keep placo's in a small tank but as they grow they are transfered to a pond at my friends place. (HE LOVES THEM)

I understand you may be new to the fishworld so welcome. Good luck and you have came to the right place.
 
actually, plecos can grow up to 18" & 24" at ful size, way not ok for that size of a tank. I say bring them all back and research before you listen to the great suggestions of the fish store guy.
 
tottenchris said:
i just started my freshwater tank and i have 1 pleco and 3 small bala sharks in a 30gal tank. i need to know what to do next in the terms of new fish. im hoping to add new fish in next week somtime. i now about the cycle and that has nearly completed. thanks.
You cannot keep balas and plecos in a 30 gallon tank. Please take them back and get smaller fish. :)
 
is it ok to have them in that small of a tank for about 6 months if i don't add anything else or maybe a few neon tetras. im moving then and will then have space for a lot bigger tank. if it is ok when i move what is the best size tank for the fish. they are all small now and i know they can get really big.
 
6 months is too long, in my opinion and experience. I made the exact same mistake with my very first 55 gallon tank and bought 6 bala sharks, 2 tinfoil barbs and a sailfin pleco. I swear it was only about 3 months before each of the very small bala sharks were over 6 inches long and the tinfoils were doubled in size. The pleco was by far the fastest growing and was such a strain on the bioload that I was having regular bacteria/algea blooms.

This Bala Shark topic is just a pet-peeve for me. I have no clue why they are so commonly found in LFS around the world and it always seems that no LFS employee cares about who they sell them to for whatever sized tank. These fish can be hurt be being kept in too small of a group and it usually results in stress-out balas that are open to Ich and other problems. We all realize that they can be bought small, but they are very fast growing fish and not even one is really appropriate for a 30 gallon tank.

Sorry that you got stuck in this situation. It is a common occurance so don't feel like you made the mistake. The LFS is at fault 100%. Like everyone points out, do some research and if you don't find the exact fish you want, then you will at least be 'armed' with the right questions to ask the next time you are thinking about a fish to purchase.
 
AquariaCentral.com