Do you ever regret getting rid of your fish/fishes?

Cloud-9

AC Members
May 11, 2003
216
0
0
Reidsville, GA
Visit site
Reading through some of the messages on this board today sort of put me in a melancholy mood. I remember all of the cichlids that I had kept for many months, enjoyed, and then taken back to the dealer for various reasons. Sometimes, it was due to having to relocate for a job, other times simply because I wanted to make room for something else (attention deficit will make you do things like this). Anyway, almost-always those cichlids that I took back ended up in a very bad way. To my knowledge, none of them ended up with knowledgeable and properly equipped owners. Here are some examples:

1) Tilapia Buttikoferri - I bought this fish as a 3.5" juvenile. I kept it until it was about 6" total lenght and then took it back to open the tank for a hemichromis elongatus. The next time I went to the shop, I saw the fish was severely beat up, tore up fins, mouth, and was in the worst shape. They put it in a tank with a very aggressive Oscar.

2) Crenicichla Xingu - I kept this pike for quite a while. "training" it to eat jumbomin, dorored, and krill instead of guppies. I had to give it up to move to a smaller home. I came back to the dealer a few weeks later and saw it in a big display tank. It had gotten bigger, but it was in bad shape. The inside of its mouth was tore up, the flesh looked like minced white fish. I don't know what could do that. I wanted to take her back but I had already given away the big tank.

3) Green Terror - Another fish that I bought as a very small specimen. A gold saum. I took it back the same time I did the pike. I don't know what happened since it sold quickly.

Is there a fish, or fishes, that you really regretted to get rid of?
 
Rarely. I do burn out on particular tanks after some years, and trade in the inhabitants to make room for some newer interest or just for a change.

Some fish that are close to pets, or that I have kept for the majority of their life span, move from their original display to utility retirement homes, where they can live out their span. Those are the ones that I would regret having less than good care after leaving me, so they do stay.
 
I gave away my one foot long Snakehead to a Chinese LFS and the guy told me he ate it. No joke. But no regrets on my part, it was just taking up tank space and money (i.e. feeders).
 
^^^^^HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA thats funny



i have not had any regrets. all the fish i got rid of needed to go bc they were not compatible.

the only regret i have is that i would have gotten more money out of a full sized male auratus. the pecker head gave me two bucks, then sold it for 30+. im still bitter
 
Hi cloud 9,

The only regret i have is buying 3 pair of wild caught Aulonocaras of which 5 died on me within 2 weeks time.
That’s when i decided never to buy any wild caught anymore.
I never had to say goodbye to one of my cichlids during the 6 years I'm having them, with the exception of the ones who went to cichlid-paradise.

Jimmy
 
AquariaCentral.com