PDA

View Full Version : Do you ever regret getting rid of your fish/fishes?



Cloud-9
06-09-2003, 10:36 AM
Reading through some of the messages on this board today sort of put me in a melancholy mood. I remember all of the cichlids that I had kept for many months, enjoyed, and then taken back to the dealer for various reasons. Sometimes, it was due to having to relocate for a job, other times simply because I wanted to make room for something else (attention deficit will make you do things like this). Anyway, almost-always those cichlids that I took back ended up in a very bad way. To my knowledge, none of them ended up with knowledgeable and properly equipped owners. Here are some examples:

1) Tilapia Buttikoferri - I bought this fish as a 3.5" juvenile. I kept it until it was about 6" total lenght and then took it back to open the tank for a hemichromis elongatus. The next time I went to the shop, I saw the fish was severely beat up, tore up fins, mouth, and was in the worst shape. They put it in a tank with a very aggressive Oscar.

2) Crenicichla Xingu - I kept this pike for quite a while. "training" it to eat jumbomin, dorored, and krill instead of guppies. I had to give it up to move to a smaller home. I came back to the dealer a few weeks later and saw it in a big display tank. It had gotten bigger, but it was in bad shape. The inside of its mouth was tore up, the flesh looked like minced white fish. I don't know what could do that. I wanted to take her back but I had already given away the big tank.

3) Green Terror - Another fish that I bought as a very small specimen. A gold saum. I took it back the same time I did the pike. I don't know what happened since it sold quickly.

Is there a fish, or fishes, that you really regretted to get rid of?

Mr.Jingles
06-09-2003, 10:44 AM
nope

kribs, rams, blue acaras. no regrets.

RTR
06-09-2003, 10:52 AM
Rarely. I do burn out on particular tanks after some years, and trade in the inhabitants to make room for some newer interest or just for a change.

Some fish that are close to pets, or that I have kept for the majority of their life span, move from their original display to utility retirement homes, where they can live out their span. Those are the ones that I would regret having less than good care after leaving me, so they do stay.

shyguyjon
06-09-2003, 12:33 PM
I gave away my one foot long Snakehead to a Chinese LFS and the guy told me he ate it. No joke. But no regrets on my part, it was just taking up tank space and money (i.e. feeders).

dbcb314
06-09-2003, 1:34 PM
^^^^^HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHA thats funny



i have not had any regrets. all the fish i got rid of needed to go bc they were not compatible.

the only regret i have is that i would have gotten more money out of a full sized male auratus. the pecker head gave me two bucks, then sold it for 30+. im still bitter

jimbo
06-09-2003, 2:32 PM
Hi cloud 9,

The only regret i have is buying 3 pair of wild caught Aulonocaras of which 5 died on me within 2 weeks time.
That’s when i decided never to buy any wild caught anymore.
I never had to say goodbye to one of my cichlids during the 6 years I'm having them, with the exception of the ones who went to cichlid-paradise.

Jimmy