A good way to euthanize a fish?

JamesBenjamin

Hopeless Romantic
Nov 7, 2002
114
0
0
49
NoVA
www.thejoyofliving.net
I've had one tiger barb that was pretty bad off, and have been thinking about letting him go to 'the big fish bowl in the sky' for a few days now. Last night when I got home from work, he was so bad off I decided to help him there. I know I've read about the 'best' way to to do this, some people say whack it with a hammer, or cut off its head (ewwww!) some say freeze it (torture! :( ) some say putting the fish in a mix of alchohol & tankwater... I didn't have any alcohol around (just wine, and something tells me that wouldn't work as well :p ) so I decided to try ammonia, the stuff I cycled my tank with. Well, it was a sad time, but he did die quickly. I netted him out of the tank, put him in a tall glass with 2" of tank water in it, then poured about a cup of ammonia in there, basically doubleing the liquid in the glass. He had one final spazz, and was dead a second later. I miss him, but this was really for the best. I just wanted to share what I tried, maybe it will help someone else out...

:(
 
i dont think ammonia is/was a good way. It likely just burned his gills so bad he couldnt breathe.
 
Sorry to hear about your barb :( .

Personally I think I'd go with alcohol or freezing, but it sounds like it was quick.

Condolences.
 
Originally posted by pinballqueen
Freezing them isn't as bad as you would think...Put them in a bag of water, and put it in the freezer...their metabolism slows down gradually and they just go to sleep...

I second this method.... I have read this before.
 
Originally posted by pinballqueen
Freezing them isn't as bad as you would think...Put them in a bag of water, and put it in the freezer...their metabolism slows down gradually and they just go to sleep...

I also add ice cubes/ ice water into the bag
just before I put it in the freezer to make things
even quicker.
 
I've heard several arguments against freezing ailing fish. Apparently, they thrash about and have a very tough time. If I ever had to euthanize a fish, I'd like to find a method that was the most humane (but I reckon everyone else does too)

How does the alcohol method work?
 
AquariaCentral.com