open top vs closed top?

my03

AC Members
Jun 27, 2004
35
0
0
Visit site
hey guys im just about to order my tank and i need to decide wether or not i want a closed or open top?

first of all, how much impedence will glass lids have on the lighting provided by M/h or flurecent tubes?

how serious is the issue of evaporation creaing higher salinity levels? what are ways to overcome this? is this what "chillers" are for?

thanks
 
Originally posted by my03

first of all, how much impedence will glass lids have on the lighting provided by M/h or flurecent tubes?

If the glass is kept clean, somewhere around 5%-10% of light will be blocked, depending on the thickness of glass and wether or not its tempered. Acrylic sheets will allow more light through, but are more expensive, need to be thicker to resist warping, and tend to scratch.

If the glass is not frequently cleaned of all salt or any other build up, it will drastically reduce light transmission, by 50% or more.


how serious is the issue of evaporation creaing higher salinity levels?

Well, open tops most certainly increase your evaporation, the increase in air exchange will force you to add larger amounts of freshwater to compensate each day, but the benefits generally outweigh the negatives.

what are ways to overcome this? is this what "chillers" are for?

chillers do exactly what the name conveys, they cool down the tank water, much the same way your refrigerator works. Many people find that using an open top allows them to get by without a chiller, as the additional evaporation cools the tank water.

BTW- if you do decide to go with an open top, consider buying a sheet or two of eggcrate (plastic light diffuser grid) many of us use that to prevent the occasional fish from carpet surfing.
 
on my tank i originally had open top, but i had about 4 fish that weren't supposed to be jumpers go carpet surfing. so then i tried some of the lighting grid that looks like a tic-tac-toe board and that blocked a little too much light for my taste. i then went to just regular old glass tops. i clean them once a week and they seem to block very little light. they also stopped my tank from evap 3 gal of water a day. now it just lets about 1 gal evap.
 
Originally posted by quantim0
lighting grid that looks like a tic-tac-toe board and that blocked a little too much light for my taste.

you probably installed it upside down. ;)
 
AquariaCentral.com