Why mother nature knows best...

OrionGirl

No freelancing!
Aug 14, 2001
14,053
343
143
Poconos
Real Name
Sheila
Just heard about this. Makes glowing danios look like a near miss.

The normal life cycle for sea living salmon is a tough one. Eggs are laid in FW rivers--the adults migrate from the sea to the place they were born. The fry live in FW for a period of time, then migrate to the sea, where they live until maturity--9 years. The they fight their way back, spawn, and die. As a result, moderation of river ways, habitat, and pollutants leave them clinging to survival--fewer and fewer make it back to reproduce each year.

So someone had a bright idea--rainbow trout are in the same family as salmon, but they can reproduce in just one year! So, salmon were genetically modifed with rainbow genes. Viola--a salmon that will survive spawning, and breeds much sooner. What a great trick, right?

Then, the vegetation along the spawning rivers was examined. 40% of the vegetation utilized carbon from the decaying bodies of the salmon. More than 90% of the carbon found in the insects comes from the dead fish. Without the yearly infusion of dead salmon, 40% of the streamside trees, forbs, and grasses will die off. Ditto for 90% of the insects--and the other animals the utilize these plants and bugs will be out of luck.

So, by attempting to 'help' one critter in the system, the whole thing will be toppled.
 
:( :sad :rant:

That's awful. Just about as much forethought as those who introduced cane toads to australia. Gee, that was sure a grrrrreat idea.
 
Ecosystems cannot be tinkered with lightly. They are closed systems... It can only ever work if you have energy from outside to add to the ecosystem.

However, if this tinkering were accomplished, it would cause chaos for a decade or three, and then stabilize (potentially after extinctions...). The salmon would still die after 9 years, littering the water with dead fish as well as all the live ones heading back to sea. The big question would be whether the live fish would be killed by water filled with 1/8th rotting salmon.
 
AquariaCentral.com