The at Petco said... Should I believe him?

Beeker

Aquariaholic
Oct 8, 2004
803
0
0
The guy at Petco said... Should I believe him?

I am new to planted tanks. I am getting ready to set mine up so I stopped at Petco and looked at the plants. I asked a couple questions and was told that I need to buy some type of floride additive to put in the tank if I want to keep live plants. I've never seen anybody mention it here. Is it true? Also, do I need a specific plant light for a planted tank or is a regular aquarium light enough? This is what the kid told me there, although, he didn't know about the watts per gallon stuff. I thought that was odd. Please help.
 
Last edited:
Flourite is very helpful, but most people regard it as optional. It really depends on what you want to grow. Some plants need more care than others. The care they require can include light, Co2, and other nutirents. But, each plant's requirements varry greatly. So you will have to research any plant you want to buy.

There are plants that grow in all light levels. So you can either :

A) Find a plant that will grow in your exisitng light level.

B) Get more light to grow the plant you want.

Would you rather get more light or settle for a low light plant? Sometimes settling isn't all the bad. There are some nice low light plants.
 
I'm planning on low light plants. The plants are only to make my fish happy. I know I need more watts (I only have a 40 watt tube on a 75 gal. tank) but I don't know if it is true that I need a special type of light like the guy said or just a regular aquarium light. I have learned the hard way that I can't always trust the people at the stores.
 
A regular aqurium type light will due.

I would try to get closer to 1 watt per gallon if you can. That will give you a lot more plants to choose from. But it all depends on the plant you want to grow. Pick the plant first, then the light if you have the budget to get more light. If not, try some anubias or similar low light plants.
 
Beeker am I dreaming? I thought you just ordered a new light...

When it comes to light AFAIK there isn't any particular 'special kind' that plants need. Plants want light, plain and simple - there are a number of types that will work for aquarium plants, but I think the majority of people stick to fluorescents in one form or another - either regular T12/T8s or power compact are what I see people using most of the time, and they're all succesfully growing plants. The only kind of light that is unsuitable TMK is incandescent, because it puts out a lot of heat and much less light per watt than fluorescent.

I sure hope they meant Flourite (the substrate) and not flouride - plants, TMK, don't need cavity prevention for their teeth like people do ;)
Flourite isn't a necessity, as jonathan mentioned. It's great for heavily planted tanks with demanding plants, but for a tank where you're going for low-light, low maintenance, I'd stick with the substrate you've got and see how things go.

I too am wary of LFS employee advice - sometimes it's good, sometimes it's just plain wrong, usually it's somewhere inbetween. Trust your instincts, and never be afraid to get a second opinion :)
 
Last edited:
Blinky,
You are right, but sadly, it isn't enough wattage.

Either I have to send it back and get a double, or I have to find a 48 inch tube that is at least 80 watts. Is it possible to find a 48" flourescent tube that is at least 80 watts? I am really getting disheartened having to make my fish wait like this. It seems as if nothing is working out in our favor.

What does AFAIK and TMK mean? Also, the kid said "floride" and held up this bottle of some liquid. A yellow bottle with a picture of plants on the front. I think the brand was Tetra Aqua. Maybe he meant florite but was too ignorant to really know what it was. It is really irritating to deal with people who work at pet stores and know nothing about their stocks.
 
Last edited:
Beeker said:
Blinky,
You are right, but sadly, it isn't enough wattage. Either I have to send it back and get a double, or I have to find a 48 inch tube that is at least 80 watts. Is it possible to find a 48" flourescent tube that is at least 80 watts? I am really getting disheartened having to make my fish wait like this. It seems as if nothing is working out in our favor.
Well, with flourescent lighting, if you added an 80 watt bulb to a a setup that only had 60 watt ballasts, you wouldn't see any benefit at all. The ballasts control what wattage of bulb you can use, not vice versa. So, send it back if you can.
 
I guess it was destined to be sent back. It has other minor defects anyway.
 
Me too. That is a thought. I'll look around. Maybe I could find one and dress it up a bit to make it look nice and save myself some money.
 
AquariaCentral.com