Restocking the tank of death

chinnp

In denial of MTS
Mar 24, 2005
540
3
0
I have a 55 gallon display tank in my living room I'd really like to restock. The current inhabitants thrive in there and live peacefully. I have in the tank right now:

1 Angelfish (approx 6-7" tall)
6-7 danios (hard to count b/c they move so fast)
1 Upside down cat (possibly more, but I see him occasionally he's a very good hider)
3 Glo-lites
6-7 cory cats of different varieties
1 male platie

Obviously, the tank is somewhat understocked. I've had it set up approximately a year and 3 months. Ammonia and Nitrite are 0, Nitrate is approx 5.0, and ph is somewhere between 7.6-7.8 (hard to tell with the test kit, but that's what my tap water tests).

Like I said, the inhabitants seem to thrive, but when I add any new fish they seem to die pretty quickly. I've lost 3 angels, 3 platies, and 6 otos among other things. Usually they'll die within a day or two of adding them. I've heard otos can be hard to acclimate, but hadn't heard that about angels or platies.

I'd like to add 2-3 more angelfish, 3 female platies (to produce snacks for the angelfish), 3 more glo-lites and a handful of cory cats. Obviously, I wouldn't add these at once. Anyone have any ideas what's killing the new fish? When I add fish to my other two tanks (which have similar water parameters), I don't have this problem.
 
Do you buy them right after the fish store gets them in? It helps to wait until after they have been there a week +. If you are afraid they will sell out, ask them to hold them for you. That way, it gives some time for the weak ones to die out.

Why you are having trouble with just that tank? I don't know. Maybe you should set up a quarantine tank, just to be safe.
 
I would suggest like 4 Kuhli Loaches... very nive looking fish!
 
I hadn't considered loaches at all. I know clowns get way too big and might not mesh well with the smaller fish in this tank once they do. How big do kuhli's get?
 
khuli's are small, about 4 inches max and they hide all day. Get yourself 2 or 3 weather loaches, Dojo loach, they get up to 7 or so inches, are very hardy, can survive an outdoor pond, temps as low as 50F, and are a ton of fun. After they are in your tank a few days, the fun starts. They nibble your fingers for flakes, and synchronize swimming routines. If you see these guys don't pass them by. They don't look like much to start, kind of small and greyish but once acclimatized they regain a beautiful bronze color. My loaches are the highlight of my tank.
 
AquariaCentral.com