Regulating pH

Apr 21, 2005
65
0
0
47
Invercargill, New Zealand
Hey there, new to this forum, and fairly new to keeping tropical fish.

I've had my 40 litre (10gal??) tank for approx 18 months with some success..
I originally stocked it with Neon & silvertip tetras and a red finned shark.
Over the last year I've had fish die and replaced them with dwarf neon gouramis (both died fairly quickly), a couple of swords, and most recently Blue rams, 1 survived about a week the other about 3 weeks.

I currently have 1 red finned shark (not the original) 3 platys, 3 glowlight tetras and 1 silvertip tetra (who is the only surviving original fish)

I test the pH of water everytime we do a water change. Before it goes in the tank its around the preferred 7.0 mark. We are on a rainwater tank supply, so theres no chlorine or any other chemicals in our water
The test water from the tank is generally around 6.0-6.2
The pH test kit I have we can't be sure of the exact pH as we just compare the colour of the water to a chart that came with the kit.
Is there any other kit that may give a more accurate reading?
Also, we had been given a product called Proper pH 7.0 which we were told would change the water pH level to around 7.0 which is supposedly ideal for a community tank. Trouble is it doesn't seem to change the pH very much, is there a better product available for this? How regularly should we add this stuff?

I suspect my rams died from incorrect pH or perhaps ammonia or nitrates?? Should we be testing for these things too??

Cheers
 
With new unestabilished tanks, you should definately test for ammonia and
Ntirite, with estabilished tanks that aren't undergoing large changes it isn't necessary however nitrAte is something you should test for to estabilish maintenance needs. Any time anything goes wrong i.e. fish death, ammonia and nitrite should be tested for.

Ideal PH is a myth hands down no two ways about it. Even if it weren't a myth ideal would be somewhere in the 7.6 range for a good stable tank. Anything in a bottle that claims to lower PH or stabilize it either one is generally snake oil and will cause you much Gnashing of teeth. Ph can be raised fairly effectively by adding carbonate or bicarbonate (crushed coral, baking soda, dolemite etc.) however you should not tamper with these things without a KH test kit, as too much of anything will also cause you trouble.
If you are on rainwater, most likely you have little or no carbonate in your water. What you do have will be consumed by the natural processes in the tank, and thus lower your ph. Eventually your Ph will crash pretty hard. Read anything you can find on OTS (old tank syndrome) and remember a tank doesn't need to be old for OTS to be in effect.

Raising carbonate (Kh) quickly can be stressful to your fish. I would suggest a series of 10% water changes until the tank and tap read identical levels. You should put some tap water in a shallow bowl for 24 hours and then test Ph. There are often processes in our pipes that alter Ph, and letting the water stabilize with the air will give you true correct readings.
Once your tank and your tap are equal then you can work on adjusting to a stable level that you want.
IMO Kh should be around 2-3 degrees minimum, some folks would argue that it isn't necessary to be that high in a non-planted tank, but I like stability and 3 degrees seems to be the mark IME.
If you don't have a KH test, use your Ph for a reference. Start with very very small amounts of baking soda in your small water changes For a 10 g I would suggest 1/16 teaspoon of baking soda in a gallon of water, and then do a water change. repeat this process for several days until you reach something in the range of 7.4-7.6 and then figure out how much baking soda you need to keep that level based on your maintenance schedule. If you find that Kh/ Ph is lowering between water changes, a small amount of crushed coral bagged and in the filter will counteract this. Do not add baking soda directly to the tank, it is very fast to dissolve and swing kh/ph levels. Your fish will not like rapid swings.
HTH
Dave
 
Welcome to AC! :)

If your fish are living well at 6.0-6.2 DO NOT fuss with the pH, because the more you try to fuss with the pH, the more stress it is on the fish because of the flucuations (going up and down).

These pH altering chemicals that you see on the market are A WASTE in my opinion/experience. They will alter the ph only for a short time, and then it will go right back to where it was originally, and if you look ask around here or any other place, people will usually tell you this "A stable pH is better than a constantly swinging one".

If it were me, I would leave the pH alone, because tetras and rams actually prefer acidic water. (which your pH seems to be) because that is where they are originally from in the wild (the amazon generally has soft, acidic water).

If you need to alter the pH for any reason at all whatsoever, then use natural products (they are much safer, and actually work!).

If you ever need to lower the pH, you usually hear of people use Driftwood or Peat.

If you ever need to raise (buffer) the pH you usually hear of people using things like Crushed Coral or Limestone.

Hope This Helps at least a little bit! :)
 
FYI, blue rams and most tetras prefer soft water with low PH. Fishes will adapt to the PH lvls as long as its relatively constant, I have blue rams in PH of 7.6 and they are fine. What you don't want is the PH lvls changing drastically as that can kill the fish. Test your water right after you do a water change and then test it throughout the week and see if there's a noticeable change. If it does not then PH isn't likely the culprit in your fish deaths. If it drops by over .5 then its a good idea to buffer it by putting a little crushed coral in the water or filter.

The likelier culprit are the ammonia, nitrite, and nitrate lvls. ammonia and nitrites are toxic to fishes even at low lvls, nitrates are a little less so but needs to be monitored as well. You definately want to know these lvls and do water changes once they get to a certain lvl.
 
Thanks for your replies

I think one of my main problems is getting conflicting advice. We have two petshops in town, I haven't yet developed a preference for either one.

One of them, (we'll call it shop A) has a large variety of fish to choose from, this is the one I generally buy from for that reason. The other shop (shop B) doesn't seem to have such a wide range.
They also differ in how they say you should run your tank. Shop A basically says you can put almost anything in a tank and alter the pH to 7.0.
Shop B says this not the best idea.

Just visited shop B in my lunch break and told him my pH problem. He told me that I shouldn't worry about trying to alter it to keep everyone happy and its probably because I tried to alter it that the rams died. He asked a few more questions, and thinks that the water may be too hard?? He said if I bring in a sample of the water to him that he'll do a test on it and go from there.
 
I used baking soda...about a tbs per 15 g of water. I eyed it and then tested the water before adding it to the tank. thing is I don't think it is stable...I mean that I was worried that it would build up or be filtered out causing constant shifting. I also bought a pH up chemical, but had no directions on ammount. I am just keeping my pH at what my water is rather than changing and fluctuation all the time. If that helps.

I also used something that was a neutralizer...it put it up or down, for whatever your tank is, but that seemed a waste of money.

You want fish to be equiped to deal with the water you have, don't just average it out and hope everyone is happy. same with all the other conditions...temp, salt, etc.

It seems from what you say, that store B might be wiser. Research on here, ask, ask, ask, and see how it compares to what the store says. ppl here are good. If they match opinions, then you got your store. Also, find out about details. Knowlegable stores will know fish vocabulary and you will see who knows what they are talking about if you go in knowing about hte processes, even if you don' t know the solutions.

good luck.
 
I would tend to agree with Pet shop B up to the point of the water being too hard. Chances are that your water is too soft if anything, and as pointed out this wouldn't be the cause of the fish death.
Ideal is to match your tank and tap so that water changes keep things perfect. If it proves that you don't have enough Kh from the tap to keep it stable then refer to the earlier post. Stability is the primary key IMO, and matching to tap is the secondary key. I have had trouble keeping my tanks stable at less than 3 DKH and I do weekly 30-60% water changes. Either way avoid the stable ph powder, and anything that claims to lower Ph. The stuff that claims to raise Ph is essentially baking soda at an inflated price, so don't waste your money there.

It is very common to get bad and conflicting advice from fish stores. Don't hate them for it, just do your research and learn the facts. of the three LFS's that I frequent there is only one that gives good accurate advice about much of anything. It took me quite a while to learn to trust them despite the good advice.

Taking a water sample in isn't a bad idea at all, get the Kh levels the Gh levels and anything else they offer to test for, and keep track of them. I do this routinely to verify my own test kits. Just don't let them sell you a bottle of anything without researching for second opinions.
Dave
 
Well back from having my tank water tested and the guy at the shop was a little surprised by the results.

He stuck a big tube thing in that had lights on that lit up and I think he said it measures the conductivity of the water. He said it should be around 6-8??
My water registered almost 20??

He did some other tests, he didn't tell me what they were for, but he took a sample of the water in a tube and dropped some liquid stuff in
1 - he was trying to make the water go yellow, which it did with about 2 drops of the solution. He was surprised by this result for some reason.
2 - he was trying to make it go blue, and 10 drops of the solution later, it went blue.. he said that wasn't good.
3 - was for pH, and that turned yellowish green colour, which he said was fine.

I wish he had explained the things to me more, and maybe I should have written this stuff down.
He said to start doing 20-30% water changes weekly, and then take another sample of water back to him for more tests.
 
I would be concerned that this guy is going to try ti sell you chemicals that you may not need, or could get a cheaper version elsewere.
 
AquariaCentral.com