Carbon/charcoal in the filtration or not?

saganco

RIP my precious kitty baby
Oct 29, 2006
239
0
0
Colorado
There seems to be two sides of having carbon in the filtration with a planted tank. My charcoal is in need of changing again, and I just don't know whether or not I should even be using it or not. Can some of you very experienced plant growers help me out? I do have a nasty case of some dark green "stuff" growing all over my plants, and the algae eaters can't/won't clean it off. Could the charcoal have caused this somehow? If not, should I or should I not change out the charcoal and continue using it?

Also, any good links for diagnosing the "stuff" on my plants and finding out how the heck to get rid of it?

Thanks all.
 
I use carbon only on an as needed basis, like after a major replanting and kicking up lots of gunk or after medication. I don't see a need to use it constantly as that can get expensive and is really unnecessary unless you're overstocked.

dark green stuff growing on the plants sounds like bearded black algae, a very tough algae problem to deal with. It's not caused by the use of carbon, most likely there is some nutrient/light/CO2 imbalance that is promoting it's growth. Trim the really affected leaves and bleach/scrub off the algae if it's on any equipment or decor. Dosing Flourish Excel may help, or adding CO2 another way. From there, have lots of plants and make sure they're growing well by adding the necessary nutrients and fertilizers.

http://www.thekrib.com/Plants/Algae/red-algae.html
 
Most likely you have an imbalance in lighting/ferts that is causing the algae. Carbon filters all ferts out of the water, so don't use it. It may be that the carbon was taking ferts out of the water, which would cause the algae. Or maybe you just are not dosing enough ferts. Try not using carbon for a while and see if that helps. If not, keep the carbon out and dose more ferts.
 
carbon has it's place . Using it can help reduce nasties in between water changes. many choose to use a scheduled water change, carbon is very effective at removing some meds from the water.

the dark green algae...is it slimey?

could be a few different algae.some are not true algae IE blue green algae is actually a cyanobacer(bacteria)
 
not................
 
I have C in my filter, but it's quite old. I stuffed the bag like a turkey 3 months ago, and I've let a little of it back out twice now to allow better water flow (C is no longer active but adds a little to mechanical aspect of filter, provides a little more surface area for bact. growth). I put fresh in ~1/year and I'd put fresh in following any course of meds.
 
OK, thanks everyone for the opinions on using charcoal! It's out of the new tank's filter and will come out of the other one next weekend when we clean the filter again. Hubby has been visiting www.plantgeek.com where he's learning how to get a handle on the algae problem - plants and algae... his department, not mine!

Thanks to all of you again for your help. Probably made my life a lot easier with future algae issues! :bowing:
 
AquariaCentral.com