Mafia #6.....The Play

[MikenDanielle]

right so...he feels 'screwed' because 'you went public on him' = I presume outing him as a mafia.

so there are two possibilities :

1. DP did PM you about roles, which meant your mafia roles as assigned by the don, which means you're both mafia
2. DP did not PM you but you're saying he did in order to have him lynched...which makes you mafia...

...show me the flaw in this logic and I'll consider not voting for you.

3. I said it to make you think, if I wanted him lynched I would have voted for him but I voted for iceh2o.... that sounds like a major flaw to me.

Defeat the enemy from within - Sun Tzu - The Art of War

 

[Coler]

Thanks

I vote to lynch Mikendanielle

 

[clown-lover]

Coler - I have to agree with your vote..

I vote to lynch Mikendanielle

 

[charlie_stubbs]

well im not 100% sure about ice, but i am about you mike. if we bag a mafia on the first night is that a record???
I vote to lynch Mikendanielle

 

[Coler]

Thanks

I vote to lynch Mikendanielle

all subject to developments of course.


choo-choo...is that the lynch train starting up ?

 

[clown-lover]

So far I have 17/24 players have posted
7/24 have voted

IceH20 (2) - Hooked (69), Mikendanielle (72)
Mikendanielle (5) - zSand(76), IceH20(82), Coler(122), Clown(123), charlie(124)

 

[clown-lover]

all subject to developments of course.


choo-choo...is that the lynch train starting up ?

Agreed with the possible developments, as far as the train goes.. He is setting off either

1) Newbie Alarms
2) Mafia Alarms

I'm not going to go through and re-iterate what you have already posted, and as of this point, the case you have made really has me questioning him based on the information at hand.

 

[Hooked Newbie]

Folks, I do not disagree with the take on Mike at all, but please look at Ice. He has definitely raised my suspicions and would be the more dangerous of the 2 if they are both mafia. If we have 2 of them at this point, we're off to a great start.

CL & Charlie give me pause with their willingness to jump so quickly without posting their reasoning. Coler was a proven innocent last game and seems to be playing innocent this game, but the first day should be filled with suspicion and not following. IMO, the following would be another way for mafia to lay low.

 

[clown-lover]

Hooked.. Build a case since you think he is guilty. If you have evidence to support it I am an open minded individual and will consider the facts. At this point I have more alarms from Mike.

 

[IceH2O]

3. I said it to make you think, if I wanted him lynched I would have voted for him but I voted for iceh2o.... that sounds like a major flaw to me.

Defeat the enemy from within - Sun Tzu - The Art of War

You only voted me because Hooked did. You needed to plant the suspicion and see if anyone bit. You were 100% sure DP was mafia but voted for me because someone else did.

You started a train but forgot to set the brake, now its running over the top of you.

Again I say to the townies to investigate me, whats one more day? If I'm mafia you got me, if I'm innocent then no reason to vote me unless you are mafia.

Dr. Spock once wrote, "Parenting is about choices and deciding what's best for your child." It also can be reworded to say "Protecting is about choices and whats best for your town".