Read my posts and make up your own mind. I'm not necessarily "building a case" as I am attempting to stop a train. If we have a totally lopsided vote, people will tend to focus a bit too much and not look for the next mafia.... We have 7 to find this game. What were your reasons, your case? As far as I read, you just agreed with Coler and threw the vote in.
Mafia #6.....The Play
- Thread starter Rbishop
- Start date
Read my posts and make up your own mind. I'm not necessarily "building a case" as I am attempting to stop a train. If we have a totally lopsided vote, people will tend to focus a bit too much and not look for the next mafia.... We have 7 to find this game. What were your reasons, your case? As far as I read, you just agreed with Coler and threw the vote in.
I think that's a valid analysis although you lost me when you started quoting Dr. Spock. I'm not going to retract or change my vote yet for 2 reasons. 1) I don't want a conclusive "train" that the mafia will be able to jump on and be hidden by. 2) I am still suspicious of you as I was in the last game where you posted in a similar manner.
We do agree on one point though... Any townies with investigative abilities, please investigate Ice or myself.
To help look over posts and pull quotes for your case it makes it easier if you set your post count to 100 posts per page. That way you don't have to go back and forth among multiple pages.
Last game I set it up with 100 posts per page and only had 12 pages to read through instead of 50 pages.
Last game I set it up with 100 posts per page and only had 12 pages to read through instead of 50 pages.
If you go back and compare Mike's posts to that of Joander's posts from game 5, it seems to be on the same lines as Jo was posting, other than the PMing goof up, can anyone give me and everyone else good reason to vote for MND that havent voted for him already...the only alarms I seem to be getting vibes off of him are the Newbie Alarms...we have to remember that all new joiners really don't understand the game lines....
1. you post right away you are an Innocent, everyone will think you are Mafia...
2. Defending you are Innocent will peg you as Mafia...
So if anyone can give me alot more evidence (even between the lines), I will gladly vote for him...but if he turns out to be one of us, then we REALLY need to be careful...this is exactly what the Mafia wants...us lynching each other so they dont have to waste votes on the nonkey players of the Townies...
1. you post right away you are an Innocent, everyone will think you are Mafia...
2. Defending you are Innocent will peg you as Mafia...
So if anyone can give me alot more evidence (even between the lines), I will gladly vote for him...but if he turns out to be one of us, then we REALLY need to be careful...this is exactly what the Mafia wants...us lynching each other so they dont have to waste votes on the nonkey players of the Townies...
I tend to try and keep my posting the same, its one of the things we look for in this game obviously. I don't want that to be my tell all to what side I'm playing.You have to look deeper then my post style. Obviously it can't be exactly the same but I try to keep it close.
RB, does first day end Monday night at what standard time....so everyone knows what times to put their votes in...since you are eastern time, then will it be 8 pm your time and then that would make it 7pm central standard time...
I'm keeping an open mind as night doesn't fall until Tuesday morning. I would like to hear from all players before I cast my vote. I agree that we need to keep looking and not just concentrate on one or two Mafia candidates. There are 7 of them, afterall.
The quote should have said Protection is about choices and whats best for your town.
Simply put, to protect the town you need to make a choice, the wrong one can do more harm then good for the townies. If in doubt then look into your doubt and find the truth. The truth being I am innocent. A little hard charging but innocent none the less.
Simply put, to protect the town you need to make a choice, the wrong one can do more harm then good for the townies. If in doubt then look into your doubt and find the truth. The truth being I am innocent. A little hard charging but innocent none the less.
hey everybody, just a quick post to say hello, did not know this game was starting again so soon, and seems like i've missed a lot. Im not nearly caught up, and dont have time to get caught up now... but lol i did see some dumb comments in the begging of it by a few people. Kind of like myself last game, although i myself wasnt a mafia last game... just didnt really know how the game went. Oh well, we'll see what happens.
