Mafia #6.....The Play

[Sploke]

z i think we are thinking similarly but mad seems to me the more logical vote at this time. judge may die but im pretty sure mad is a mafia in the bag, judge im not so sure of. mike i think is mafia, but i have a feeling he may be the snitch and may even actually be helping us. i cant understand why the doc protected him, but i feel he/she would try to do so again if we vote immediately on him again. im not saying he is innocent because this has happened. far from it. i need to know why the doc has protected him when he is the most obvious choice to me as mafia aside from mad. interesting days here in acville, time for first lunch. gotta love a town with two of every meal in one crazy day

If we're going to vote to lynch mike again, I'd say we need to establish a very clear case. If there is more doubt in the doctor's mind, the doc will save mike again, I would imagine. So those that are in favor of seriously getting Mike out, need to build a solid case to base a lynch vote on, to remove all doubt. That way we might have a chance of actually taking some action that will give us some information to go on the next day.

And Doc, whoever you are, it seems to me that it would be more helpful to try and save people from mafia hits rather than landslide lynch votes where the entire town thinks them mafia. Just something to think about for the next go-round...

 

[joander123]

Jeez, jo settle down...Obviously we can't be sure of jm because she hasn't posted but that still doesn't mean she's completely innocent...There still has to be that tiney amount suspicion for everybody...

i just dont like the idea of voting to lynch someone who is going to be booted out of the game anyways.

 

[jpappy789]

Well if you read Cs's post you would notcie that he said that mad was a better choice to lynch not jm, so I don't know why you were tweaking on him...

 

[charlie_stubbs]

jo i believing judge is innocent because she hasnt posted is just as dangerous as believing she's mafia because of same. i didnt say she was either or. i am suspicious of her lack of posting but not enough so to justify a vote for her at this time im sticking with mad unless someone builds a case otherwise. for the record i have moved you 1 degree closer to mafia jo as you are trying also to deflect suspicion from judge, who wont be taken from my watchlist until her fate is proven, but wont be my vote anytime soon either barring future devolopments regarding the "judgegate" affair

 

[ZSandmann]

I'm not dropping the JM idea but there is a lot of time in this Day so I'll get off her back and hope she arrives. After rereading my own list in Mad's quote above I have to see if I'm on to something.

I vote to lynch Hooked Newbie.

HN was the first vote for Ice, it became a small train, then HN jumped to Mad which became a pretty sizable train. The common link is HN who was the conductor of both trains, choo choo!

 

[jpappy789]

The thing that confuses me about HN is that he starts two lynching trains and then retracts both votes and doesn't vote at all...interesting

 

[ZSandmann]

IceH2O: 3 -Hooked Newbie (69) MikenDanielle (72) nickmcmechan (170) sploke (432) Ogre (444)


MadCrawdad: 5- Hooked Newbie (339) Coler (395) mee-mee (398) Jensons (427) IceH2O (438) jpappy789 (465)

See HN was the first voter for each but ended up withdrawing and not voting at all.

 

[ZSandmann]

I gotta figure out how to fix this stupid text problem. When I transfer my notes from Word it screws it all up.

 

[Swayde]

OK, I know that you feel the lynch JMax thing is a valid plan. Here's why I disagree... we potentially lose two players your way and potentially three my way. BUT we get NO NEW information if we do it your way. We're basically giving the mafia a free ride for the day... letting them slip into their roles with no defending required. We start day three exactly where we are now, but with two fewer players.

I would rather take a chance on getting a mafia tonight and have lots of new information than just let the mafia get a free day. I believe that the mafia want this free day. So those on my original list remain so at this time. Note that these are the players that are attacking me.

Sway, please look at Coler's post #406. That list DOES NOT have my name on it.. does it? That's the list that Coler pushed.

I have not counterattacked those that are accusing me of mafia-ism. My vote for Ice was based on several pieces of evidence that lead me to believe he is mafia. ZSand is acting very different from his previous games. the last two games, I got a totally innocent vibe from Zsand, now he seems more and more mafia.

Got to go.

Here's the thing OgreMKV...I read post #406 and reread it. The only person on that list that I believe to be Mafia is Madcrawdad. HOWEVER. You make NO mention of post #473 which is Coler's last post and clearly marks you, Mad and ZS as his suspects! I even asked you if you missed the post entirely, or if you are a LIAR.



Here is my revised list of Mafia suspects, from strongest to weakest...

1. Madcrawdad
2. Ogremkv
3. Zsandmann
4. IceH20
5. Unsure

 

[MikenDanielle]

i just dont like the idea of voting to lynch someone who is going to be booted out of the game anyways.

How do you not like the idea... different scenerio... Tim has cancer and Bob does not... one of these two must die. Tim has been givin 2 months to live, Bob is healthy... who would you pick to die if you had to choose? I can;t make this seem any simpler. And we do get info from JM being lynched, we find out if she is infact mafia or innocent... if she just slides away into the darkness do we get to find out her role?

i rather a silent jm then an active mike. he follows whoever isn't against him just to sav his own skin. if it was him or some innocent role player im sure he would choose himself. Thats prime mafia tactics waiting to happen, thats why i don't like mafia going beyond this round. With the loss of coler and the mafia stronger this game we don't need someone who just follows and adds to confusion.

Have you passed a grade 3 comprehension test? I follow whoever is not against me?? Not that this is true.. but what do you expect me to do?? Follow those who are against me??? Seriously use a little common sense and I think we will be doing better.